Unit 4: Pricing practices & factor pricing
Managerial Economics-I notes · PTU syllabus (BBAGE 101-18)
On this page
Unit summary
Pricing is one of the most important managerial decisions. This unit covers pricing practices, commodity pricing, the economics of advertising costs, and factor pricing — demand and supply of factors of production, collective bargaining, rent, profit and interest, real versus nominal interest rates and basic capital theory.
After this unit you can
- Explain cost-based, competition-based and strategic pricing practices
- Discuss commodity pricing and the economics of advertising
- Explain the demand and supply of factors and collective bargaining
- Explain the theories of rent, profit and interest, real vs nominal interest and basic capital theory
PTU syllabus topics
- Pricing practices
- commodity pricing and economics of advertisement costs
- demand and supply of factors of production
- collective bargaining
- rent
- profit and interest
- real vs. nominal interest rates
- basic capital theory
Topic 1
Pricing practices
Cost-plus (full-cost) pricing
Average cost plus a mark-up
Marginal cost pricing
Price covers at least marginal cost, used for extra orders
Going-rate pricing
Match competitors' prices
Penetration pricing
Low launch price to win share
Skimming pricing
High launch price for early adopters
Peak-load and discrimination pricing
Different prices at different times or segments
Product-line and bundle pricing
Pricing a range together
Transfer pricing
Internal prices between divisions
Psychological pricing
₹99, ₹999
Price
P = AVC + AFC + mark-up
Mark-up on cost
(P − AC) ÷ AC
Optimal mark-up
Mark-up on MC = 1/(e − 1) — the lower the elasticity, the higher the mark-up
Example
Average cost ₹80 and desired profit 25% on cost: price = 80 + 20 = ₹100. If e = 3, the profit-maximising mark-up over MC is 1/(3 − 1) = 50%.
Launch price
High
Low
Aim
Recover costs quickly from early buyers
Capture large market share
Suits
Unique, high-technology, inelastic demand
Mass-market, elastic demand, strong competition
Example
New smartphone, then price cuts
New data plan, new streaming service
Risk
Attracts rivals
Low early profit
Basis
Own cost
Rivals' prices
Strength
Simple, ensures profit margin
Avoids price wars
Weakness
Ignores demand and competition
Ignores own cost
Peak users pay a price higher than off-peak users, as with electricity, train and airline fares
Example
Price discrimination and skimming: a cinema charges ₹150 on a weekday morning and ₹300 on a Saturday evening for the same film, because demand is less elastic at the weekend (third-degree price discrimination). A new phone is launched at ₹80,000 and reduced to ₹60,000 after a year (skimming).
Topic 2
Commodity pricing
Commodity pricing (wheat, rice, crude oil, metals, cotton) is largely determined by demand and supply in organised markets, but with special features.
- Standardised product
- Grade and quality are the same, so price is uniform
- Volatility
- Weather, global supply and speculation cause swings
- Inelastic supply
- Crops take a season to grow
- Government intervention
- Minimum Support Prices (MSP), buffer stock, export bans
- Futures markets
- NCDEX, MCX allow hedging and price discovery
- Cobweb effect
- Farmers react to last year's price
Producers base this season's output on last season's price, so prices overshoot and oscillate around equilibrium
Minimum support price
Floor price protecting farmers
Surplus bought by FCI
Buffer stock
Buy in surplus, sell in shortage
Stabilises price
Price ceiling
Maximum price to protect consumers
Shortage and black market
Example
The cobweb cycle in onions: a high price this year leads farmers to plant more. Next year's large crop pushes the price down. Farmers then plant less, and the following year the price rises again. Prices and output swing because supply responds to last year's price.
Topic 3
Economics of advertising
Advertising (selling) costs are spent to shift demand rightward and make it less elastic by building brand loyalty.
Advertising increases demand and reduces its price elasticity
- Purpose
- Inform, persuade, remind
- Advertising elasticity
- EA = % change in sales ÷ % change in advertising
- Optimal outlay
- Spend until marginal revenue from the last rupee of advertising equals one rupee
- Dorfman–Steiner rule
- Advertising ÷ sales = advertising elasticity ÷ price elasticity
- Effect on cost
- Raises total cost but may lower average cost by spreading fixed cost over more sales
- Market structure
- Heaviest in monopolistic competition and oligopoly
Consumers
Information, choice
Raises price, manipulates wants
Firms
Larger sales, brand loyalty, entry for new products
Wasteful in a zero-sum rivalry
Society
Funds media, supports employment
Barrier to entry for small firms
Advertise until the extra revenue from one more rupee falls to one rupee
Example
Is the campaign worth it? an advertising spend of ₹10 lakh raises sales by 5,000 units. Each unit contributes ₹300 after variable cost, so the gain is ₹15 lakh and the net benefit ₹5 lakh. The firm should keep increasing advertising until the extra contribution from the last rupee spent equals one rupee.
Topic 4
Demand and supply of factors of production
Factors earn factor incomes: land → rent, labour → wages, capital → interest, entrepreneurship → profit.
- Derived demand
- Demand for a factor comes from demand for the product it makes
- Marginal physical product (MPP)
- Extra output from one more unit
- Marginal revenue product (MRP)
- MRP = MPP × MR
- Value of marginal product (VMP)
- VMP = MPP × price (perfect competition)
- Hiring rule
- Hire up to the point where MRP = wage
The equilibrium wage equals the marginal revenue product of the last worker hired
At high wages the income effect (more leisure) outweighs the substitution effect, so hours offered fall
Payment
A factor is paid its MRP under perfect competition
Assumes perfect competition and homogeneous units
Scope
Explains demand for factors
Ignores supply side and bargaining
Hiring rule
Employer hires until MRP = wage
Hard to measure MRP for managers
Collective bargaining
Collective bargaining is negotiation between employers and trade unions on wages, hours and conditions of work.
- 1
Union submits a charter of demands
- 2
Management examines and gives its counter-proposal
- 3
Negotiation meetings
- 4
Settlement and written agreement
- 5
Implementation and grievance handling
- 6
If talks fail — conciliation, arbitration, adjudication
- Wage effect
- Can raise wages above the competitive level
- Bilateral monopoly
- Single union facing a single employer — wage lies between the two limits
- Industrial peace
- Reduces strikes and lockouts
- Participation
- Workers share in decisions
- Legal basis in India
- Industrial Disputes Act and the Industrial Relations Code
The wage depends on the relative bargaining strength of union and employer
Example
How many workers to hire: the marginal product of the 1st to 4th worker is 10, 8, 6 and 4 units, and the product sells at ₹50. Marginal revenue product is ₹500, ₹400, ₹300 and ₹200. If the wage is ₹300, the firm hires 3 workers, the point where MRP equals the wage.
Exam tip
Demand for a factor is a derived demand: it depends on the demand for the product the factor makes.
Topic 5
Rent
- Contract rent
- Payment under a contract for use of land or a house
- Economic rent
- Surplus earned by a factor above its transfer earnings (what it would earn in the next best use)
- Quasi-rent
- Short-run surplus on man-made fixed assets such as machinery
Ricardian theory: rent arises because land differs in fertility and location; the poorest (marginal) land earns no rent; better land earns differential rent.
| Grade of land | Output (quintals) | Rent (differential) |
|---|---|---|
| A (best) | 40 | 40 − 20 = 20 |
| B | 30 | 30 − 20 = 10 |
| C (marginal) | 20 | 0 |
Because supply is fixed, rent is price-determined by demand — a pure surplus
Ricardo (differential)
Rent due to fertility differences; no rent on marginal land
Assumes only land, ignores location and rent on marginal land
Modern (demand-supply)
Rent is the price of any factor with less than perfectly elastic supply
None major
Quasi-rent (Marshall)
Temporary rent on man-made assets in the short run
Only short run
Example
Ricardian rent on three plots: each plot costs ₹10,000 to cultivate. Grade A yields produce worth ₹20,000, grade B ₹15,000 and grade C ₹10,000. Rent is the surplus over cost: A earns ₹10,000, B earns ₹5,000 and C, the marginal land, earns no rent.
Exam tip
In Ricardo's theory rent does not enter price: corn is not high because rent is paid; rent is paid because corn is high.
Topic 6
Interest
Interest is the price paid for the use of capital (loanable funds).
Classical (real)
Interest equates savings (supply) with investment (demand)
Ignores money and bank credit
Loanable funds
Interest is determined by demand and supply of loanable funds (savings, bank credit, dis-hoarding vs investment, hoarding)
Hard to separate stock from flow
Keynes (liquidity preference)
Interest is the reward for parting with liquidity, set by demand for and supply of money
Ignores real forces such as productivity
The interest rate adjusts until the demand for loanable funds equals the supply
People hold money for transaction, precaution and speculation; the rate falls when money supply rises
- Gross interest
- Net interest + risk premium + management charges
- Net interest
- Pure payment for capital
- Real rate
- Nominal rate adjusted for inflation
Real vs nominal interest rates
Real rate
r ≈ i − π (nominal rate minus inflation)
Exact
(1 + i) = (1 + r)(1 + π)
Ex-ante
Expected inflation used
Ex-post
Actual inflation used
Example
A deposit pays 7% while inflation is 5%: the real return is about 2%. If inflation is 8%, the real return is −1%, so savers lose purchasing power.
Topic 7
Profit
Profit is the reward of the entrepreneur for organising production and bearing risk. Unlike rent, wages and interest, it is a residual and can be negative. Several theories explain why profit arises.
- Gross profit
- Revenue minus explicit costs
- Net (economic) profit
- Revenue minus explicit and implicit costs
- Normal profit
- Reward for entrepreneurship just enough to keep the firm in business — included in cost
- Super-normal profit
- Surplus above normal profit
Risk-bearing
Profit rewards risk-taking
Hawley
Uncertainty
Profit arises from uninsurable uncertainty
Knight
Innovation
Profit rewards innovation and disappears when imitated
Schumpeter
Dynamic surplus
Profit arises from change
J. B. Clark
Monopoly power
Profit due to market power
Kalecki
Wage of management
Profit pays for organising skill
Taussig
Example
Theories in practice: a firm that launches the first food-delivery app in a city earns high profit until rivals copy it (innovation theory, Schumpeter). A builder who starts a project without knowing future prices earns profit for bearing uninsurable uncertainty (Knight).
Exam tip
Match each theory to its economist: risk-bearing (Hawley), uncertainty-bearing (Knight), innovation (Schumpeter), dynamic (J.B. Clark).
Topic 8
Basic capital theory
- Capital
- Produced means of production — machinery, buildings, stock
- Capital goods
- Used to produce other goods
- Roundabout production
- Making tools first raises later output (Böhm-Bawerk)
- Present value
- Value today of future income, PV = R ÷ (1 + i)ⁿ
- Marginal efficiency of capital (MEC)
- Expected rate of return on the last unit of capital
- Investment rule
- Invest while MEC > interest rate
Example
An asset yields ₹11,000 next year; at 10% interest its present value is 11,000 ÷ 1.10 = ₹10,000. If it costs less than ₹10,000, buy it.
A firm invests up to the point where the MEC falls to the interest rate
Key terms
- Cost-plus pricing
- Price = average cost + mark-up
- Penetration pricing
- Low initial price to gain market share
- Skimming pricing
- High initial price for early buyers
- Cobweb effect
- Price oscillation because supply responds with a lag
- Advertising elasticity
- Percentage change in sales per percentage change in advertising
- Derived demand
- Demand for a factor arising from demand for its product
- Marginal revenue product
- Extra revenue from one more unit of a factor
- Collective bargaining
- Negotiation between employers and unions
- Economic rent
- Surplus over transfer earnings
- Liquidity preference
- Demand for money to hold
- Fisher equation
- Real interest ≈ nominal interest − inflation
- Present value
- Current value of future income
Quick revision
- Pricing: cost-plus, going rate, skimming, penetration, discrimination, transfer, peak-load.
- Commodity prices: volatile; MSP, buffer stock, futures; cobweb effect.
- Advertising shifts demand right and makes it less elastic; optimum where marginal revenue = ₹1.
- Factor demand is derived; hire until MRP = wage; collective bargaining and bilateral monopoly.
- Rent: Ricardian, modern and quasi-rent. Interest: classical, loanable funds, liquidity preference.
- Profit: risk (Hawley), uncertainty (Knight), innovation (Schumpeter).
- Real rate ≈ nominal − inflation; invest while MEC > interest.
Important exam questions
Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).
Short-answer questions
- Q1.What is cost-plus pricing?
- Q2.Differentiate skimming and penetration pricing.
- Q3.What is the cobweb effect?
- Q4.What is advertising elasticity?
- Q5.What is derived demand?
- Q6.What is MRP?
- Q7.What is collective bargaining?
- Q8.Define economic rent and quasi-rent.
- Q9.State Keynes's liquidity preference theory.
- Q10.Differentiate between real and nominal interest rates.
- Q11.State Schumpeter's innovation theory of profit.
- Q12.What is the marginal efficiency of capital?
Long-answer questions
- Q1.Explain the various pricing practices followed by firms.
- Q2.Explain commodity pricing and the economics of advertising.
- Q3.Explain the marginal productivity theory of factor pricing and collective bargaining.
- Q4.Explain Ricardo's theory of rent and the modern theory.
- Q5.Explain the theories of interest.
- Q6.Explain the theories of profit.
- Q7.Discuss real versus nominal interest rate and basic capital theory.
Stuck on this unit?
Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Managerial Economics-I, or to ask about studying BBA at Synetic.
