Unit 3: Reconciliation & methods of costing
Cost Accounting notes · PTU syllabus (BCOM 201-18)
On this page
Unit summary
Costing records and financial records must agree, and different industries need different costing methods. This unit covers the reconciliation of cost and financial accounts, process costing, contract costing, and marginal costing with an introduction to cost–volume–profit analysis.
After this unit you can
- Explain why cost and financial profits differ and prepare a reconciliation statement
- Prepare a process account with normal loss, abnormal loss and equivalent units
- Prepare a contract account and compute the profit to be taken
- Apply marginal costing and cost–volume–profit analysis
PTU syllabus topics
- Need for reconciling cost and financial accounts
- reasons for differing profits
- preparation of reconciliation statements
- process costing
- contract costing
- marginal costing and cost-volume-profit analysis basics
Topic 1
Reconciliation of cost and financial accounts
Cost and financial accounts are maintained separately so their profits often differ; a reconciliation statement explains the difference and checks both sets of records.
Items only in financial accounts
Interest, dividends, income tax, donations, loss on sale of assets, preliminary expenses written off, discount, fire loss
Items only in cost accounts
Notional rent, interest on own capital
Over- or under-absorption of overheads
Differences in stock valuation
FIFO or weighted average vs other methods
Different depreciation methods
Abnormal losses and gains
- 1
Start with the profit as per cost accounts
- 2
Add income only in financial accounts
- 3
Add items overcharged in cost accounts — over-absorption
- 4
Deduct financial expenses and losses not charged in costing
- 5
Deduct under-absorption and notional charges
- 6
Adjust stock valuation differences
- 7
Arrive at the profit as per financial accounts
| Reconciliation statement | ₹ |
|---|---|
| Profit as per cost accounts | 1,00,000 |
| Add: Interest and dividends received (financial items) | 8,000 |
| Add: Over-absorbed administration overhead | 5,000 |
| Less: Preliminary expenses written off | (3,000) |
| Less: Loss on sale of machinery | (4,000) |
| Less: Under-absorbed selling overhead | (2,000) |
| Profit as per financial accounts | 1,04,000 |
Treatment of items in reconciliation
| Starting from cost profit | |
|---|---|
| Income only in financial books (interest, dividend, rent received) | Add |
| Expenses only in financial books (loss, donation, tax) | Deduct |
| Over-absorption | Add |
| Under-absorption | Deduct |
| Overvaluation of closing stock in costing | Deduct |
| Undervaluation of closing stock in costing | Add |
Debit side
Items that reduce financial profit relative to cost profit
Credit side
Items that increase it
Balancing figure
Profit as per financial books
Topic 2
Process costing
Process costing is used where production is continuous and the output of one process becomes the input of the next — chemicals, textiles, sugar, paper, cement.
- 1
Raw materials
- 2
Process I
- 3
Process II
- 4
Process III
- 5
Finished goods
- 6
Each process has its own account showing material, labour, overhead, losses and output
Production
Continuous, standardised
Customer orders, non-standard
Cost record
Per process and period
Per job
Cost per unit
Average of the period
Specific to the job
Industries
Chemicals, sugar, textile
Printing, repairs, furniture
Normal loss
Inevitable — cost borne by good units; scrap value credited to the process
Abnormal loss
Avoidable — valued like good units; scrap sale credited, balance to costing P&L
Abnormal gain
Actual loss less than normal — valued like good units; debited to the process account
Scrap
Sale value credited
By-products
Sale value credited
Normal output
Input − normal loss units
Cost per unit
(Total cost of the process − scrap value of normal loss) ÷ normal output
Abnormal loss value
Abnormal loss units × cost per unit
Abnormal gain value
Abnormal gain units × cost per unit
Example
Input 1,000 units. Costs: material ₹12,000, labour ₹4,000, overhead ₹2,500. Normal loss 10% sold at ₹5 per unit. Actual output 850 units (abnormal loss 50 units). Cost per unit = (18,500 − 500) ÷ 900 = ₹20.
| Dr | Units | ₹ | Cr | Units | ₹ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| To Material | 1,000 | 12,000 | By Normal loss (scrap at ₹5) | 100 | 500 |
| To Labour | 4,000 | By Abnormal loss (50 × ₹20) | 50 | 1,000 | |
| To Overhead | 2,500 | By Transfer to Process B (850 × ₹20) | 850 | 17,000 | |
| Total | 1,000 | 18,500 | Total | 1,000 | 18,500 |
- 1Debit — Process account (50 units at ₹20 = ₹1,000)
- 2Credit — Sale of scrap 50 × ₹5 = ₹250 (cash)
- 3Credit — Costing profit and loss account for the balance ₹750
- 4Account closes to nil
Equivalent units
When some units are partly complete (work-in-progress), costs are spread over equivalent units.
Equivalent units
Number of units × percentage of completion
Total equivalent units
Units completed + equivalent units of closing WIP
Cost per equivalent unit
Cost ÷ total equivalent units
Separate treatment
Material, labour and overhead may be at different completion levels
Example
1,000 units were started; 800 completed and 200 remain 50% complete. Equivalent units = 800 + 200 × 50% = 900. Total cost ₹19,800 gives ₹22 per equivalent unit. Completed units = 800 × 22 = ₹17,600; closing WIP = 100 × 22 = ₹2,200.
Opening WIP
Treated separately — only work done this period is costed
Merged with current production
Complexity
Higher
Simpler
Cost control
Better
Less precise
- Inter-process profit
- Transfers between processes at cost plus profit; unrealised profit in stock is provided for
- Joint products
- Products from the same process — cost split by physical units or sales value
- By-products
- Minor outputs — credited at net realisable value
Topic 3
Contract costing
Contract costing (terminal costing) is used for large, long-duration jobs at the customer's site — building, bridges, roads, ships.
Each contract is a separate cost unit
Large and long-term
Mostly direct costs
Work at the contractee's site
Payment in stages — progress payments
Retention money held back
Profit estimated on work certified
- 1
Contract account opened for each contract
- 2
Debit — material, wages, direct expenses, plant depreciation and overhead
- 3
Credit — materials returned, plant at the end, work in progress
- 4
Work certified by the architect or engineer
- 5
Cash received less retention money
- 6
Notional profit found
- 7
Profit credited to P&L according to the stage of completion
- Work certified
- Value of work approved by the architect
- Work uncertified
- Work done but not yet certified, valued at cost
- Retention money
- Percentage of the certified value (say 10–20%) held back until completion
- Cash received
- Work certified less retention
- Escalation clause
- Adjusts price for cost changes
- Notional profit
- Value of work certified plus uncertified work, less cost to date
Profit to be taken to the profit and loss account
| Stage of completion | Rule |
|---|---|
| Less than 25% | No profit — the contract is at an early stage |
| 25% to less than 50% | ⅓ × notional profit × (cash received ÷ work certified) |
| 50% to less than 90% | ⅔ × notional profit × (cash received ÷ work certified) |
| 90% or more (nearly complete) | Estimated total profit × (work certified ÷ contract price) — or notional profit less a reserve |
Example
Contract price ₹10,00,000. Cost to date: materials 2,50,000, wages 1,50,000, expenses 50,000, plant depreciation 20,000 = ₹4,70,000. Work certified ₹6,00,000 (60% complete); cash received 80% = ₹4,80,000; work uncertified at cost ₹30,000.
| Contract account | ₹ | ₹ | |
|---|---|---|---|
| To Materials | 2,50,000 | By Work certified | 6,00,000 |
| To Wages | 1,50,000 | By Work uncertified (at cost) | 30,000 |
| To Expenses | 50,000 | ||
| To Plant depreciation | 20,000 | ||
| To Notional profit c/d | 1,60,000 | ||
| Total | 6,30,000 | Total | 6,30,000 |
Notional profit
6,30,000 − 4,70,000 = ₹1,60,000
Completion
6,00,000 ÷ 10,00,000 = 60% (50 to 90% range)
Profit taken
⅔ × 1,60,000 × (4,80,000 ÷ 6,00,000) = ₹85,333
Reserve
1,60,000 − 85,333 = ₹74,667 carried forward
Duration
Long — more than a year
Short
Location
Site of the customer
Factory
Profit
Taken in stages
On completion
Overheads
Mostly direct
More indirect
Treatment of plant and materials in a contract
| Treatment | |
|---|---|
| Plant used | Depreciation charged, or plant at cost debited and plant at the end credited |
| Materials unused at site | Credited at closing |
| Materials returned to stores or transferred | Credited |
| Abnormal losses | Charged to costing P&L |
| Sub-contract cost | Debited to the contract |
Topic 4
Marginal costing and cost–volume–profit analysis
Marginal cost is the variable cost of producing one additional unit (direct material, direct labour, direct expenses and variable overhead); marginal costing charges only variable costs to products and treats fixed costs as period costs.
Contribution
Sales − Marginal (variable) cost
Contribution per unit
Selling price − variable cost per unit
Profit
Contribution − Fixed cost
P/V ratio
Contribution ÷ Sales × 100 = Change in contribution ÷ Change in sales
Break-even point (units)
Fixed cost ÷ Contribution per unit
Break-even sales
Fixed cost ÷ P/V ratio
Margin of safety
Actual sales − Break-even sales
Sales for target profit
(Fixed cost + Target profit) ÷ P/V ratio
Example
Selling price ₹20, variable cost ₹12, fixed cost ₹40,000. Contribution per unit = ₹8; P/V ratio = 8 ÷ 20 = 40%. Break-even = 40,000 ÷ 8 = 5,000 units = ₹1,00,000 sales. At 8,000 units: contribution 64,000 − fixed 40,000 = profit ₹24,000; margin of safety = 3,000 units (₹60,000) = 37.5%. For a profit of ₹40,000: units = (40,000 + 40,000) ÷ 8 = 10,000.
Below the break-even point the firm makes a loss; above it the shaded wedge is profit; the margin of safety is the sales above the break-even
At zero sales the loss equals the fixed cost; the line crosses zero at break-even and rises with slope equal to the P/V ratio
Costs charged to product
Variable only
Variable and fixed
Fixed cost
Period cost — written off in full
Part carried in stock
Stock valuation
Lower (variable cost)
Higher (full cost)
Profit when stock rises
Lower
Higher
Useful for
Decisions — pricing, make or buy, shutdown
Statutory reporting
Pricing
Special orders and price floors
Make or buy
Compare variable cost with purchase price
Key factor
Rank products by contribution per unit of scarce resource
Product mix
Maximise contribution
Shut-down decision
Continue if contribution is positive
Export and discount decisions
- Assumptions
- Costs split into fixed and variable; constant selling price and variable cost per unit; production equals sales; single product or constant mix
- Limitations
- Real costs are not always linear; fixed cost changes beyond capacity; ignores time value; short-term view
Key terms
- Reconciliation statement
- Statement explaining the difference between cost and financial profits
- Process costing
- Costing for continuous production in stages
- Normal loss
- Unavoidable loss in a process
- Abnormal loss
- Avoidable loss above normal
- Equivalent units
- Partly complete units expressed as complete units
- Contract costing
- Costing for long, large jobs at the customer's site
- Work certified
- Value of contract work approved by the architect
- Retention money
- Part of the certified value withheld until completion
- Contribution
- Sales less variable cost
- P/V ratio
- Contribution as a percentage of sales
- Break-even point
- Level of sales at which there is neither profit nor loss
- Margin of safety
- Sales above the break-even
Quick revision
- Reconcile: start with cost profit; add financial income and over-absorption; deduct financial losses and under-absorption.
- Process costing: cost per unit = (cost − scrap of normal loss) ÷ normal output; abnormal loss at cost.
- Equivalent units = units × % completion.
- Contract: notional profit; 25–50% → ⅓, 50–90% → ⅔ × notional profit × cash ÷ certified.
- Contribution = sales − variable cost; BEP = fixed cost ÷ contribution per unit; MoS = actual − BEP sales.
- Marginal costing treats fixed cost as a period cost.
Important exam questions
Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).
Short-answer questions
- Q1.Why do cost and financial profits differ?
- Q2.State four items found only in financial accounts.
- Q3.What is process costing? Give two industries using it.
- Q4.Differentiate between normal loss and abnormal loss.
- Q5.What are equivalent units?
- Q6.What is retention money?
- Q7.What is notional profit in a contract?
- Q8.Define contribution and P/V ratio.
- Q9.What is the break-even point? What is the margin of safety?
- Q10.Differentiate between marginal costing and absorption costing.
Long-answer questions
- Q1.Explain the reasons for differences in cost and financial profits and prepare a reconciliation statement.
- Q2.Prepare a process account with normal loss, abnormal loss and abnormal gain.
- Q3.Explain equivalent units with an illustration.
- Q4.Prepare a contract account and find the profit to be transferred.
- Q5.Explain marginal costing and cost–volume–profit analysis with a break-even chart.
- Q6.Calculate break-even point, margin of safety and target sales from given data.
Stuck on this unit?
Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Cost Accounting, or to ask about studying B.Com at Synetic.
