Unit 3: Capital budgeting & dividend decisions
Financial Management notes · PTU syllabus (BCOM 501-18)
On this page
Unit summary
Capital budgeting commits large funds for many years, so methods of evaluation matter; dividend policy decides how earnings are shared. This unit covers the meaning and process of capital budgeting, non-discounted and discounted evaluation methods, capital rationing, and dividend policy — determinants, types, and the Walter, Gordon and MM models.
After this unit you can
- Explain the meaning, importance and process of capital budgeting
- Evaluate projects using payback, ARR, NPV, PI and IRR
- Explain capital rationing
- Explain dividend policy and the Walter, Gordon and MM models
PTU syllabus topics
- Meaning and process of capital budgeting
- discounted and non-discounted evaluation methods (payback period, ARR, NPV, benefit-cost ratio, IRR)
- capital rationing
- determinants and types of dividend policy
- Walter's Model
- Gordon's Model
- MM Hypothesis
Topic 1
Capital budgeting: meaning and process
Capital budgeting is the process of planning and evaluating long-term investment proposals — new plant, expansion, replacement, R&D.
- Importance: large funds, long-term effects, irreversible, affects risk and growth.
- 1
Identify investment opportunities
- 2
Estimate cash flows
Incremental, after-tax
- 3
Evaluate proposals
Payback, ARR, NPV, IRR, PI
- 4
Select projects
- 5
Implement
- 6
Post-completion audit
- Cash flow after tax (CFAT) = Profit after tax + Depreciation (non-cash).
Example
Payback and NPV: a machine costs ₹1,00,000 and returns ₹40,000 a year for 4 years. Payback = 2.5 years. At 10%, the present value of inflows is 40,000 × 3.170 = ₹1,26,800, so NPV = ₹26,800 and the project is accepted.
Topic 2
Evaluation methods
IRR is the rate where NPV = 0. Accept the project if the cost of capital is below the IRR (NPV positive)
Non-discounted
Payback period, accounting rate of return (ARR)
Discounted
Net present value, profitability index (benefit–cost ratio), internal rate of return, discounted payback
Payback period
Initial investment ÷ Annual CFAT (equal flows); cumulative method for unequal flows
ARR
Average annual profit after tax ÷ Average investment × 100
Average investment
(Initial cost − Salvage) ÷ 2 + Salvage + Working capital
NPV
PV of cash inflows − PV of outflows
Profitability index
PV of inflows ÷ PV of outflows
IRR
Rate at which NPV = 0 (by interpolation)
Example
Project cost ₹1,00,000; CFAT ₹30,000, ₹40,000, ₹50,000, ₹30,000 for 4 years; cost of capital 10%. Payback = 2 years + 30,000/50,000 = 2.6 years. PV factors 0.909, 0.826, 0.751, 0.683 → PV = 27,270 + 33,040 + 37,550 + 20,490 = ₹1,18,350. NPV = ₹18,350 (accept). PI = 1.18.
| Method | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| Payback | Simple; emphasises liquidity | Ignores time value and post-payback cash flows |
| ARR | Uses accounting data; considers whole life | Ignores time value; uses profit not cash |
| NPV | Time value; maximises wealth; additive | Needs cost of capital; ignores size differences |
| IRR | Time value; easy to compare with cost | Multiple IRRs possible; reinvestment assumption at IRR |
| PI | Useful under capital rationing | May conflict with NPV for mutually exclusive projects |
Exam tip
For mutually exclusive projects, if NPV and IRR conflict, prefer NPV — it assumes reinvestment at the cost of capital, which is more realistic.
Topic 3
Capital rationing
Capital rationing occurs when funds are limited and the firm cannot accept all profitable (positive NPV) projects.
- External rationing: market imperfections, inability to raise funds. Internal rationing: self-imposed budget limits.
- Divisible projects: rank by PI and accept in order until funds run out (partly accept the last).
- Indivisible projects: try feasible combinations and choose the one with the highest total NPV.
Example
Ranking by profitability index: the budget is ₹10 lakh. Project A costs 5 with NPV 2 (PI 1.40); D costs 1 with NPV 0.35 (PI 1.35); B costs 4 with NPV 1.2 (PI 1.30); C costs 6 with NPV 1.5 (PI 1.25). Choose A, D and B: cost ₹10 lakh, total NPV ₹3.55 lakh.
Topic 4
Dividend policy: determinants and types
Dividend policy decides the proportion of earnings paid as dividend (payout) vs retained (retention).
- Determinants: profitability and stability of earnings, liquidity, growth needs, cost of external funds, shareholders' preference, taxation, legal restrictions (Section 123), loan covenants, control, inflation, market conditions.
- Types of dividend policy: stable dividend per share, stable payout ratio, regular + extra dividend, irregular, no dividend.
- Forms of dividend: cash, bonus shares (stock dividend), interim and final; buy-back as an alternative.
Example
Stable dividend policy: a company pays ₹5 per share every year and raises it only when it is confident earnings will stay higher. Investors such as retirees value this predictability.
Exam tip
Types: stable, irregular, no dividend and residual. Determinants: earnings, liquidity, growth needs, taxation and shareholder preferences.
Topic 5
Walter, Gordon and MM models
Walter's model
P = [D + (r ÷ k)(E − D)] ÷ k
Gordon's model
P0 = E (1 − b) ÷ (k − br), where g = br
MM irrelevance
P0 = (D1 + P1) ÷ (1 + ke)
- Walter: if r > k (growth firm) — retain all (payout 0%); r < k (declining firm) — pay out 100%; r = k (normal firm) — dividend policy irrelevant.
- Gordon ("bird-in-hand"): investors value current dividends more than uncertain future gains; with r > k, retention raises price; with r = k, irrelevant; with r < k, payout raises price.
- MM hypothesis (1961): in perfect markets, dividend policy is irrelevant — value depends on earning power of assets; what shareholders gain in dividends they lose in share price (home-made dividends).
Example
Walter: E = ₹10, D = ₹4, r = 15%, k = 10%. P = [4 + (0.15 ÷ 0.10)(6)] ÷ 0.10 = (4 + 9) ÷ 0.10 = ₹130. At D = 0, P = [0 + 1.5 × 10] ÷ 0.10 = ₹150 — so a growth firm should retain.
View
Dividend policy affects share value
Dividend policy does not affect value
Key argument
Bird-in-hand, internal financing
Arbitrage; investors can create home-made dividends
Assumptions criticised
Constant r and k, all-equity firm
Perfect markets, no taxes, no transaction costs
Key terms
- Capital budgeting
- Planning long-term investment decisions
- NPV
- Present value of inflows minus outflows
- IRR
- Discount rate at which NPV is zero
- Capital rationing
- Limiting investment because funds are scarce
- Payout ratio
- Proportion of earnings paid as dividend
Quick revision
- CFAT = PAT + depreciation.
- Payback, ARR ignore time value; NPV, IRR, PI consider it.
- Accept NPV > 0, IRR > k, PI > 1.
- Capital rationing: rank by PI (divisible) or best combination (indivisible).
- Walter: r > k retain; Gordon bird-in-hand; MM irrelevance.
Important exam questions
Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).
Short-answer questions
- Q1.Define capital budgeting.
- Q2.What is the payback period?
- Q3.Distinguish NPV and IRR.
- Q4.What is profitability index?
- Q5.What is capital rationing?
- Q6.State Walter's conclusion for a growth firm.
Long-answer questions
- Q1.Explain the process and importance of capital budgeting.
- Q2.Explain discounted and non-discounted methods of project evaluation with illustrations.
- Q3.Explain the determinants and types of dividend policy.
- Q4.Explain the Walter, Gordon and MM models of dividend.
Stuck on this unit?
Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Financial Management, or to ask about studying B.Com at Synetic.
