Unit 4: Market structures & pricing practices
Managerial Economics notes · PTU syllabus (BCOMGE 101-18)
On this page
Unit summary
The market structure decides how much power a firm has over price. This unit covers perfect competition and the supply curve, monopoly, monopolistic competition and oligopoly, and commodity pricing practices.
After this unit you can
- Compare the four market structures
- Derive the supply curve and price and output under perfect competition
- Explain price and output under monopoly and monopolistic competition
- Explain oligopoly models and commodity pricing practices
PTU syllabus topics
- Perfect competition
- monopoly
- monopolistic competition
- oligopoly
- supply curve
- commodity pricing practices
Topic 1
Market structures overview
Market structure describes the number of sellers, the nature of the product and the ease of entry. These decide how much control a firm has over price.
Perfect competition
Very many
Identical product, price taker, free entry, perfect knowledge
Monopoly
One
No close substitute, barriers to entry, price maker
Monopolistic competition
Many
Differentiated product, selling costs, some price control
Oligopoly
Few
Interdependence, strategic behaviour, rigid prices
Duopoly
Two
Special oligopoly with two sellers
- Perfect competition
- Monopolistic competition
- Oligopoly
- Monopoly
| Feature | Perfect competition | Monopoly | Monopolistic competition | Oligopoly |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sellers | Very many | One | Many | Few |
| Product | Homogeneous | Unique | Differentiated | Identical or differentiated |
| Entry | Free | Blocked | Free | Difficult |
| Price control | None | Full | Some | Considerable |
| Demand curve | Horizontal | Downward, inelastic | Downward, elastic | Kinked or indeterminate |
| Selling cost | None | Little | High | High |
Example
Indian examples: wheat in a mandi is close to perfect competition; Indian Railways passenger service is a monopoly; restaurants are monopolistic competition; telecom is an oligopoly.
Topic 2
The supply curve
Supply is the quantity of a good that producers are willing and able to offer at each price. The law of supply: other things equal, quantity supplied rises when price rises (a direct relationship), because higher prices raise profit and draw more producers.
A rise in price from P₁ to P₂ extends supply from Q₁ to Q₂ — a movement along the curve
| Price (₹ per unit) | 10 | 20 | 30 | 40 | 50 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quantity supplied (units) | 10 | 25 | 40 | 60 | 80 |
Price of the good
Direct relation — movement along the curve
Cost of production
Wages, raw material, power
Technology
Better technology lowers cost
Prices of related goods
Alternative products
Taxes and subsidies
Tax reduces, subsidy raises supply
Number of sellers
More sellers, more supply
Expectations and weather
Future price, rainfall for crops
Lower cost, better technology or a subsidy shifts supply right; higher cost or tax shifts it left
Cause
Change in the good's own price
Change in any other determinant
Terms
Extension or contraction of supply
Increase or decrease in supply
Curve
Same curve, new point
New curve
Formula
Es = % change in quantity supplied ÷ % change in price
Es > 1
Elastic supply (manufactured goods)
Es < 1
Inelastic supply (agricultural goods in the short run)
Straight supply line through the origin
Es = 1 everywhere
Factors
Time period, spare capacity, ease of storage, cost of production
The point where the supply line meets the axes decides whether it is elastic, unitary or inelastic
An increase in demand raises both the equilibrium price and the quantity
Example
Movement and shift: when the price of wheat rises from ₹20 to ₹25 a kg, farmers offer more: a movement along the supply curve. When a good monsoon raises output at every price, the whole curve shifts right.
Topic 3
Perfect competition
Features: very many buyers and sellers, homogeneous product, free entry and exit, perfect knowledge, perfect factor mobility and no government interference. Each firm is a price taker; the industry is a price maker.
Market demand and supply fix the price, which the individual firm takes as given
Equilibrium of the firm: profit is maximised where MR = MC and MC cuts MR from below (MC is rising).
Profit = (P − AC) × Q* — the shaded rectangle
Price covers AVC, so the firm minimises loss by continuing; it shuts down only if P < minimum AVC
Free entry and exit remove super-normal profit and losses, so price equals minimum average cost
- Condition
- P = MR = MC = minimum AC
- Profit
- Normal profit only (zero economic profit)
- Efficiency
- Productive and allocative efficiency
- Entry and exit
- Entry if profit is above normal, exit if below
- Shutdown rule
- Stop if price falls below minimum AVC
- 1Find output where MR = MC and MC is rising
- 2Compare P with AC — if P > AC, super-normal profit
- 3If AVC < P < AC, loss but continue
- 4If P < AVC, shut down
- 5In the long run, free entry and exit drive P to minimum AC
Example
Should the firm produce? The market price is ₹50. MC = ₹50 at 100 units, where AC = ₹42: super-normal profit = (50 − 42) × 100 = ₹800. If the price falls to ₹38 while AC is ₹42 and AVC is ₹32, the firm makes a loss but continues — the price covers all variable cost and part of fixed cost. If the price falls to ₹30, below minimum AVC (₹32), it shuts down, because producing would add to its loss.
Topic 4
Monopoly
A monopoly has a single seller, no close substitute and strong barriers to entry (patents, licences, control of raw material, economies of scale). The monopolist is a price maker, but cannot fix both price and quantity — demand limits it.
Output is where MR = MC; price is read off the AR curve above that output — P > MC
- Equilibrium
- MR = MC and MC cuts MR from below
- Price
- Above MC; read from AR
- Profit
- Super-normal profit can persist in the long run
- Elasticity
- Operates only on the elastic part of demand (e > 1)
- Supply curve
- No unique supply curve
Price
Equals MC and minimum AC
Higher than MC
Output
Larger
Smaller
Profit (long run)
Normal
Super-normal possible
Efficiency
Productive and allocative
Neither — deadweight loss
Demand curve
Horizontal
Downward sloping
Example
Monopoly equilibrium with numbers: demand P = 100 − 2Q, so TR = 100Q − 2Q² and MR = 100 − 4Q. MC = AC = ₹20. Setting MR = MC: 100 − 4Q = 20 → Q = 20, and P = 100 − 2 × 20 = ₹60. Profit = (60 − 20) × 20 = ₹800. Under perfect competition P = MC = 20, so 100 − 2Q = 20 → Q = 40. The monopolist sells half the output at three times the price.
Exam tip
In every market-structure answer, label the graph completely — both axes, AR, MR, AC and MC, the equilibrium point E where MR = MC, the price read from AR, and the shaded profit or loss rectangle.
Price discrimination
Price discrimination means charging different prices for the same product to different buyers, not based on cost difference.
First degree
Each buyer charged the maximum price he will pay
Doctor, lawyer fees
Second degree
Price depends on quantity bought
Electricity slabs, bulk discount
Third degree
Different prices in separate markets
Student and senior fares, domestic vs export
Conditions
Markets separable, different elasticities, no resale
Example
Third-degree price discrimination: a cinema charges students ₹150 and others ₹250 for the same show. It works because the two markets can be kept apart (a student ID is checked) and their demand elasticities differ — students are more price-sensitive, so they get the lower price. The higher price is charged where demand is less elastic.
The monopolist equalises MR in each market with MC, so the market with less elastic demand pays the higher price
Topic 5
Monopolistic competition
Introduced by Chamberlin: many firms sell close but differentiated products (soaps, restaurants, clothing). Product differentiation and selling costs give each firm some control over price, with free entry in the long run.
The firm sets MR = MC and charges the price on its downward-sloping demand
Entry shifts demand left until AR touches AC — normal profit, with excess capacity because output is below the minimum-AC point
- Many sellers
- Each has a small share
- Product differentiation
- Brand, quality, packaging, service
- Selling costs
- Advertising to shift and flatten demand
- Free entry and exit
- Profits are competed away
- Excess capacity
- Long-run output below minimum-AC output
- Group
- Close substitutes treated as a "group" not an industry
Product
Identical
Differentiated
Demand curve
Horizontal
Downward sloping
Selling cost
None
Large
Long-run output
At minimum AC
Below minimum AC (excess capacity)
Price
Equals MC
Above MC
Example
Cafés in a market: each differs in taste and location, so each has some control over price. Profits attract rivals until only normal profit remains, with unused capacity.
Topic 6
Oligopoly
Oligopoly is a market with a few large sellers whose decisions are interdependent — each must guess rivals' reactions. Examples: telecom, cement, airlines, cars.
Non-collusive
Firms act independently — Cournot, Bertrand, Sweezy kinked demand
Collusive
Firms cooperate — cartels (OPEC)
Price leadership
Dominant, low-cost or barometric firm sets the price
- Few sellers
- Each is large enough to affect the market
- Interdependence
- Reaction of rivals matters
- Barriers to entry
- Scale, brand, control of inputs
- Selling cost
- Heavy advertising, non-price competition
- Price rigidity
- Prices stay stable
- Indeterminate demand
- Demand curve not fixed
Non-collusive: kinked demand curve (Sweezy)
Price rigidity is explained by the kinked demand curve: if a firm raises its price, rivals do not follow, so it loses sales (elastic demand above the kink); if it cuts price, rivals match, so it gains little (inelastic demand below the kink).
D is elastic above the kink (rivals ignore a rise) and inelastic below it (rivals match a cut). MC can move anywhere within the shaded gap in MR without changing price or output — hence price rigidity
Price stickiness
Explains why prices are sticky
Does not explain how the original price is set
Realism
Simple and intuitive
Prices do change in the real world (price wars)
Collusive oligopoly
- Formal
- Firms agree on price and quota and share profit — OPEC
- Joint profit maximisation
- Act like one monopolist: total MR = common MC
- Quota
- Each member's output limit
- Instability
- Members cheat by secretly cutting price
- Legality
- Banned in India under the Competition Act, 2002
Price leadership model
- 1One firm is the leader (dominant, low-cost or barometric)
- 2Leader sets price at its profit-maximising level
- 3Followers accept the price and sell what they like at it
- 4Leader changes price when its costs or demand change
- 5Followers copy the change
Dominant firm
Largest firm sets the price, others follow
Cement or steel major
Low-cost firm
Leader with lowest cost; others match or risk loss
Efficient producer
Barometric firm
A firm judged good at reading market conditions
Experienced smaller firm
Agreement
Tacit, informal
Formal, explicit
Legality
Easier to defend
Illegal in many countries
Stability
More stable
Prone to cheating
Control
By leader's moves
By central agency
Leader's demand = market demand − followers' supply; the leader maximises profit on this residual demand
Example
In Indian cement or steel, price increases announced by a large player are often followed by others within days — an example of price leadership in an oligopoly.
Topic 7
Commodity pricing practices
Cost-plus (full-cost) pricing
Average cost plus a mark-up
Marginal cost pricing
Price covers at least marginal cost, used for extra orders
Going-rate pricing
Match competitors' prices
Penetration pricing
Low launch price to win share
Skimming pricing
High launch price for early adopters
Peak-load and discrimination pricing
Different prices at different times or segments
Product-line and bundle pricing
Pricing a range together
Transfer pricing
Internal prices between divisions
Psychological pricing
₹99, ₹999
Price
P = AVC + AFC + mark-up
Mark-up on cost
(P − AC) ÷ AC
Optimal mark-up
Mark-up on MC = 1/(e − 1) — the lower the elasticity, the higher the mark-up
Example
Average cost ₹80 and desired profit 25% on cost: price = 80 + 20 = ₹100. If e = 3, the profit-maximising mark-up over MC is 1/(3 − 1) = 50%.
Launch price
High
Low
Aim
Recover costs quickly from early buyers
Capture large market share
Suits
Unique, high-technology, inelastic demand
Mass-market, elastic demand, strong competition
Example
New smartphone, then price cuts
New data plan, new streaming service
Risk
Attracts rivals
Low early profit
Basis
Own cost
Rivals' prices
Strength
Simple, ensures profit margin
Avoids price wars
Weakness
Ignores demand and competition
Ignores own cost
Peak users pay a price higher than off-peak users, as with electricity, train and airline fares
Topic 8
Commodity pricing
Commodity pricing (wheat, rice, crude oil, metals, cotton) is largely determined by demand and supply in organised markets, but with special features.
- Standardised product
- Grade and quality are the same, so price is uniform
- Volatility
- Weather, global supply and speculation cause swings
- Inelastic supply
- Crops take a season to grow
- Government intervention
- Minimum Support Prices (MSP), buffer stock, export bans
- Futures markets
- NCDEX, MCX allow hedging and price discovery
- Cobweb effect
- Farmers react to last year's price
Producers base this season's output on last season's price, so prices overshoot and oscillate around equilibrium
Minimum support price
Floor price protecting farmers
Surplus bought by FCI
Buffer stock
Buy in surplus, sell in shortage
Stabilises price
Price ceiling
Maximum price to protect consumers
Shortage and black market
Example
The cobweb cycle: a high onion price leads farmers to plant more; next year's large crop lowers the price; they then plant less and the price rises again.
Key terms
- Perfect competition
- Market with many sellers, identical product and free entry
- Supply curve
- Quantities offered at each price (rising)
- Price taker
- A firm that must accept the market price
- Monopoly
- Single seller of a product with no close substitute
- Price discrimination
- Charging different prices for the same product
- Monopolistic competition
- Many sellers of differentiated products
- Oligopoly
- Few sellers with interdependent decisions
- Kinked demand curve
- Oligopoly model explaining price rigidity
- Cobweb effect
- Price oscillation from lagged supply response
Quick revision
- Four market structures: number of firms, product, entry, price control.
- Law of supply; shifts of supply; elasticity of supply.
- Perfect competition: MR = MC; long run P = MC = min AC.
- Monopoly: MR = MC, price from AR, P > MC; price discrimination.
- Monopolistic competition: differentiation, selling cost, excess capacity.
- Oligopoly: kinked demand, cartels, price leadership.
- Commodity prices: MSP, buffer stock, futures, cobweb.
Important exam questions
Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).
Short-answer questions
- Q1.State the law of supply.
- Q2.Distinguish a shift of supply from a movement along it.
- Q3.List the features of perfect competition.
- Q4.Why is a monopolist's price higher than MC?
- Q5.What is price discrimination?
- Q6.What is product differentiation?
- Q7.What is the kinked demand curve?
- Q8.What is price leadership?
- Q9.What is a cartel?
- Q10.What is the cobweb effect?
Long-answer questions
- Q1.Compare the four market structures.
- Q2.Explain price and output determination under perfect competition in the short and long run.
- Q3.Explain price and output determination under monopoly.
- Q4.Explain equilibrium under monopolistic competition.
- Q5.Explain oligopoly with the kinked demand curve and price leadership.
- Q6.Explain commodity pricing practices.
Stuck on this unit?
Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Managerial Economics, or to ask about studying B.Com at Synetic.
