Unit 1 of 4 · MBA Sem 3

Unit 1: Industrial relations and trade unionism

Employee Relations notes · PTU syllabus (MBA 932-18)

7 min read9 topics10 exam questions
On this page
  1. Unit summary
  2. Concept of industrial relations
  3. Theories and approaches to industrial relations
  4. Evolution of industrial relations in India
  5. The systems approach to IR
  6. Trade unionism
  7. Trade unions and wages
  8. The Trade Unions Act, 1926
  9. The Factories Act, 1948
  10. Working hours, women and young persons
  11. Key terms
  12. Quick revision
  13. Important questions

Unit summary

Employee relations covers how employers, workers, unions and the state work together and resolve differences. This unit covers the concept, theories and evolution of industrial relations, the systems approach, trade unionism and its impact on wages, the Trade Unions Act 1926 and the Factories Act.

After this unit you can

  • Explain the concept, theories and evolution of industrial relations
  • Explain Dunlop's systems approach
  • Explain trade unionism and its impact on wages
  • Explain the Trade Unions Act 1926 and the Factories Act 1948

PTU syllabus topics

  • IR concept
  • theories and evolution
  • system approach to IR
  • trade unionism and impact on wages
  • Trade Unions Act 1926
  • Factories Act 1947
1

Topic 1

Concept of industrial relations

Industrial relations refers to the relations between management and employees, and between employers' and workers' organisations, in an industrial setting, along with the role of the state. Objectives: industrial peace, higher productivity, protection of workers' interests, fair wages and conditions, and avoidance of strikes and lockouts. Scope: labour-management relations, collective bargaining, grievance handling, workers' participation, dispute settlement and labour welfare. Importance: uninterrupted production, reduced conflict, better morale, economic growth and social justice.

Example

IR in practice: at a steel plant, management, the trade union and the state labour department meet to settle a wage demand. Good industrial relations — through regular dialogue and agreed procedures — prevent strikes and protect production.

Exam tip

Objectives of IR: industrial peace, higher productivity, worker welfare and industrial democracy.

2

Topic 2

Theories and approaches to industrial relations

The approaches differ in how they view conflict. The unitary approach sees the organisation as one team and conflict as abnormal. The pluralist approach sees competing interest groups and conflict as natural. The Marxist approach sees conflict as built into capitalism.

ComparisonApproaches to IR
Key idea
View of conflict

Unitary

Organisation is one team with common goals

Conflict is abnormal, caused by troublemakers

Pluralistic

Many groups with different interests

Conflict is natural; resolved through bargaining

Marxist (radical)

Conflict between capital and labour

Conflict is inevitable under capitalism

Systems (Dunlop)

Actors, contexts and ideology produce rules

Managed through rule-making

Gandhian

Trusteeship, non-violence, cooperation

Resolved through mutual respect and arbitration

Example

A strike over wages: the unitary view blames poor communication or agitators. The pluralist view sees a normal clash of interests, to be settled by collective bargaining. The Marxist view sees it as class conflict.

Exam tip

Dunlop's systems approach names three actors (workers, employers, government), their contexts and a web of rules.

3

Topic 3

Evolution of industrial relations in India

Industrial relations in India developed from unregulated exploitation in early factories, through the growth of trade unions and labour laws, to the present emphasis on cooperation and labour codes.

ProcessEvolution of IR in India
  1. 1Pre-independence

    Factory system, exploitation; Bombay Mill Hands Association (1890); AITUC (1920); Trade Unions Act 1926

  2. 21947–1991

    State-guided IR: Industrial Disputes Act 1947, tripartite bodies (Indian Labour Conference), INTUC and other central unions, public sector growth

  3. 31991–2019

    Liberalisation: decline of union power, contract labour, VRS, flexible employment

  4. 42019 onward

    Four labour codes consolidating 29 laws (in force from 21 November 2025); gig and platform work

Example

Milestones: the Trade Unions Act, 1926 gave unions legal status. The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 created machinery to settle disputes. After 1991, competition pushed both sides towards productivity bargaining. Four labour codes have since consolidated 29 central laws.

4

Topic 4

The systems approach to IR

The actors are management, workers and their unions, and government agencies. The contexts are technology, market or budget constraints, and the distribution of power in society. The web of rules — procedures and substantive rules — is the output of the system. John Dunlop (1958) described an industrial relations system as a set of actors, contexts, an ideology and a web of rules.

ClassificationDunlop's IR system
IR system
  • Actors

    Managers and their organisations, workers and their unions, government agencies

  • Contexts

    Technology, market or budgetary constraints, distribution of power in society

  • Ideology

    Shared beliefs that bind the system together

  • Web of rules

    Output — procedures and substantive rules on wages, hours, discipline

  • Criticism: static, neglects conflict and behavioural factors; later extended by Kochan, Katz and McKersie's strategic choice framework.

Example

Dunlop's system in a factory: management, the union and the labour department (actors) operate under new automation and a competitive market (contexts), share a belief in collective bargaining (ideology), and produce a wage agreement and grievance procedure (web of rules).

Exam tip

Draw the four elements and show the web of rules as the output.

5

Topic 5

Trade unionism

Unions perform militant functions (protecting workers through bargaining and, when needed, strikes) and fraternal functions (welfare, education and mutual help). Theories of unionism include the Marxist, Webbs' industrial democracy, Perlman's job-scarcity and Gandhian approaches. A trade union is a voluntary organisation of workers formed to protect and promote their interests through collective action.

  • Objectives: better wages and conditions, job security, welfare, participation in management.
  • Types: craft unions (one trade), industrial unions (whole industry), general unions and federations (national centres like INTUC, AITUC, BMS, CITU).
  • Functions: militant (collective bargaining, strikes) and fraternal (welfare, education, mutual help).
  • Structure: plant-level unions, industry-level federations, and central trade union organisations.

Trade Unions Act, 1926: provides for the registration of unions (minimum seven members, with at least 10% or 100 workers of the establishment, whichever is less); registered unions get legal status, immunity from certain civil and criminal liability for legitimate trade dispute activities, and a general fund and optional political fund. (The Industrial Relations Code, 2020 consolidates this law with others.)

Example

What a union does: a union negotiates a wage settlement, represents a worker in a disciplinary inquiry, and runs a credit society and education programme for members' children.

Exam tip

Discuss problems of Indian unions: multiplicity, political links, small size, weak finances and outside leadership.

6

Topic 6

Trade unions and wages

Unions influence wages through collective bargaining, but they can also affect productivity, employment and the wage gap between organised and unorganised workers.

  • Collective bargaining power lets unions raise wages above competitive levels in organised sectors — the union wage premium.
  • Effects: higher wages and benefits for members, narrower wage differentials within firms, standardised pay scales, linking of wages to productivity and cost of living (DA).
  • Limits: employers' ability to pay, product market competition, substitution of capital for labour, possible job losses, the growing non-union and contract workforce.
  • Theories: monopoly view (unions raise wages but cut employment) vs collective voice view (unions improve productivity by reducing turnover and voicing grievances — Freeman and Medoff).

Example

The union wage effect: unionised workers at a large manufacturing plant earn more than non-union workers in similar small units nearby, because the union bargains collectively. However, higher costs can lead firms to automate or outsource.

Exam tip

Present both views: unions raise wages and reduce inequality within firms, but may reduce employment.

7

Topic 7

The Trade Unions Act, 1926

The Act provides for the registration of trade unions and gives registered unions rights and immunities — immunity from civil and criminal liability for legitimate trade union activities — and requires them to keep accounts and file returns.

  • Registration: any 7 or more members may apply; in an establishment, at least 10% or 100 workmen (whichever is less) must be members.
  • Rights and privileges of a registered union: body corporate with perpetual succession; immunity from criminal conspiracy (Section 17) and civil suits (Section 18) for acts in furtherance of a trade dispute; general and political funds.
  • Obligations: maintain accounts and registers, file annual returns, spend the general fund only on permitted objects; at least half the office-bearers must be actually engaged in the industry.
  • Under the Industrial Relations Code, 2020: registration retained; recognition of a negotiating union (51% membership) or a negotiating council.

Example

Registering a union: workers in a factory with 600 workmen form a union. They need at least 7 members to apply and at least 10% or 100 workmen (whichever is less) as members — here 60 workmen.

Exam tip

Note: the Industrial Relations Code, 2020 consolidates this Act — check which law your syllabus examines.

8

Topic 8

The Factories Act, 1948

The Act covers health (cleanliness, ventilation, drinking water), safety (fencing of machinery, protection of eyes, precautions against fire), welfare (canteen, crèche, first aid, washing facilities), working hours and annual leave with wages. Applies to premises with 10 or more workers using power, or 20 or more without power, where a manufacturing process is carried on.

ClassificationProvisions of the Factories Act
Factories Act
  • Health

    Cleanliness, ventilation, lighting, drinking water, latrines, overcrowding limits

  • Safety

    Fencing of machinery, protection of eyes, fire precautions, safe lifts

  • Welfare

    Washing facilities, first aid, canteen (250+ workers), crèche (30+ women), rest rooms, welfare officer (500+ workers)

Example

Welfare thresholds: a factory employing 300 workers must provide a canteen (needed where more than 250 workers are employed), and a crèche if more than 30 women workers are employed.

Exam tip

Group the provisions under health, safety, welfare and working hours. The Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020 consolidates this Act.

9

Topic 9

Working hours, women and young persons

Children below 14 years cannot be employed in a factory; adolescents (15–18) may work only with a certificate of fitness. Overtime is paid at twice the ordinary rate.

  • Adults: maximum 9 hours a day and 48 hours a week; a rest interval of at least half an hour after 5 hours; weekly holiday; overtime at twice the ordinary wage.
  • Children below 14 may not be employed in factories. Adolescents (15–18) need a fitness certificate and work limited hours.
  • Women: traditionally not allowed between 7 pm and 6 am, now permitted in many states with safeguards and consent.

Exam tip

The syllabus lists the Factories Act as 1947; the Act is the Factories Act, 1948, now subsumed in the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020.

Example

Calculating overtime: a worker paid ₹80 per hour works 10 hours on a day. The extra hour beyond 9 is overtime at twice the ordinary rate, so they earn ₹720 + ₹160 = ₹880 for the day.

Exam tip

Remember: 9 hours a day, 48 hours a week, rest after 5 hours, overtime at double rate.

Key terms

Industrial relations
Relations among employers, employees, unions and the state
Web of rules
Output of Dunlop's IR system
Union wage premium
Extra wages earned by union members over non-members
Registered trade union
Union registered under the Trade Unions Act
Factory
Premises with 10+ workers with power or 20+ without

Quick revision

  • IR concept, objectives; unitary, pluralist, Marxist approaches.
  • Evolution of IR in India; labour codes.
  • Dunlop: actors, contexts, ideology, web of rules.
  • Unions: functions, problems; impact on wages; Trade Unions Act 1926.
  • Factories Act: health, safety, welfare, hours, young persons.

Important exam questions

Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).

Short-answer questions

  1. Q1.Define industrial relations.
  2. Q2.Name the actors in Dunlop's IR system.
  3. Q3.What is the union wage premium?
  4. Q4.How many members are needed to register a trade union?
  5. Q5.State two welfare provisions of the Factories Act.
  6. Q6.What are the working hours for adults under the Factories Act?

Long-answer questions

  1. Q1.Explain the concept, theories and evolution of industrial relations in India.
  2. Q2.Explain Dunlop's systems approach to industrial relations.
  3. Q3.Discuss trade unionism and its impact on wages.
  4. Q4.Explain the main provisions of the Trade Unions Act 1926 and the Factories Act 1948.

Stuck on this unit?

Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Employee Relations, or to ask about studying MBA at Synetic.

Planning your MBA in Ludhiana? See the MBA at SBS →

WhatsApp us