Unit 2: Credit rating, leasing and merchant banking
Management of Financial Services notes · PTU syllabus (MBA 912-18)
On this page
- Unit summary
- Concept and objectives of credit rating
- Credit rating agencies in India and methodology
- Leasing: concept and types
- Tax and legal aspects of leasing
- Origin and development of merchant banking
- SEBI guidelines for merchant bankers
- Venture capital: concept
- Venture capital guidelines and growth in India
- Key terms
- Quick revision
- Important questions
Unit summary
Credit rating, leasing, merchant banking and venture capital are key services for companies. This unit covers the concept and objectives of credit rating, credit rating agencies in India and their methodology, leasing concepts and types with tax aspects, the origin and development of merchant banking and SEBI guidelines, and venture capital concepts and guidelines in India.
After this unit you can
- Explain credit rating and the methodology of Indian rating agencies
- Explain leasing, its types and tax aspects
- Explain merchant banking and SEBI guidelines
- Explain venture capital and its regulatory guidelines in India
PTU syllabus topics
- Concept and objectives of credit rating
- credit rating agencies in India
- rating methodology
- leasing concept and types
- tax aspects of leasing
- origin and development of merchant banking
- SEBI guidelines
- venture capital concepts in India
Topic 1
Concept and objectives of credit rating
Credit rating is an expert opinion on the relative ability and willingness of an issuer to meet its debt obligations on time. It helps investors judge risk, helps good borrowers raise money at lower cost, and helps regulators.
- AAA
Highest safety
- AA
High safety
- A
Adequate safety
- BBB
Moderate safety
- BB and below
Speculative
- D
Default
Credit rating is an opinion of a rating agency about the relative ability and willingness of an issuer to meet its debt obligations in full and on time, expressed through symbols.
Long-term debt
Bonds, debentures (AAA to D)
Short-term instruments
Commercial paper, CDs (A1+ to D)
Bank loan ratings
Under Basel norms
Structured finance
Securitised instruments
Sovereign ratings
Countries (by S&P, Moody's, Fitch)
Others
IPO grading (earlier), MSME ratings, ESG ratings, mutual fund scheme ratings
| Long-term symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| AAA | Highest safety |
| AA | High safety |
| A | Adequate safety |
| BBB | Moderate safety (lowest investment grade) |
| BB, B | Moderate to high risk (speculative) |
| C | Very high risk |
| D | Default |
- Advantages: helps investors judge risk; lowers borrowing cost for good issuers; wider investor base; regulators and banks use ratings (capital adequacy).
- Limitations: ratings are opinions, not guarantees; conflict of interest (issuer pays); rating lag (IL&FS 2018 was AAA until shortly before default); rating shopping.
Example
Rating and cost of borrowing: two companies issue three-year bonds. The AAA-rated company pays 7.5% interest; the BBB-rated company must pay about 10% to attract investors because of its higher default risk.
Exam tip
A rating is an opinion, not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold.
Topic 2
Credit rating agencies in India and methodology
The rating methodology covers business risk (industry, market position), financial risk (profitability, leverage, cash flows), management quality and project risk, followed by a rating committee decision and regular surveillance.
- SEBI (Credit Rating Agencies) Regulations, 1999 govern CRAs; registered CRAs include CRISIL (1987), ICRA (1991), CARE (1993), India Ratings & Research (Fitch), Acuité, Brickwork (registration cancelled 2022), Infomerics.
- 1
Request and agreement with the issuer
- 2
Assignment of analytical team
- 3
Information gathering
Financials, management meetings, site visits
- 4
Analysis
Business risk, financial risk, management, industry
- 5
Rating committee decision
- 6
Communication to issuer and publication
- 7
Surveillance
Continuous monitoring; upgrade/downgrade/watch
- Methodology factors: business risk (industry, market position, operations), financial risk (leverage, interest cover, cash flows, liquidity), management risk (track record, governance), project risk, support from parent/government.
Example
The rating process: a company requests a rating; the agency's analysts study its accounts and meet management; the rating committee assigns a grade; the company is informed and the rating is published; it is then monitored and may be upgraded or downgraded.
Exam tip
Write the steps of the process in order — a common 10-mark question.
Topic 3
Leasing: concept and types
A lease is a contract in which the owner (lessor) gives the right to use an asset to the user (lessee) for an agreed period in return for periodic rentals. The main types are finance lease (long-term; lessee bears the risks and rewards of ownership) and operating lease (short-term; lessor bears the risks).
The lessee pays lease rentals for the right to use the asset; the lessor pays the supplier and keeps ownership
A lease is a contract in which the owner (lessor) gives the right to use an asset to another (lessee) for a period in return for periodic payments (lease rentals), while ownership remains with the lessor.
Finance lease
Long-term, non-cancellable; risks and rewards transferred to the lessee
Operating lease
Short-term, cancellable; lessor bears obsolescence and maintenance
Sale and lease back
Owner sells the asset and leases it back to free cash
Leveraged lease
Lessor borrows a large part of the cost from a lender
Direct lease
Lessor buys from the manufacturer and leases out
Cross-border lease
Lessor and lessee in different countries (aircraft)
Term
Most of the asset's economic life
Short
Cancellation
Non-cancellable
Cancellable
Risks and rewards
With the lessee
With the lessor
Maintenance
Lessee
Lessor
Accounting (Ind AS 116)
Lessee shows right-of-use asset and liability
Lessee also shows ROU asset (except short-term/low value)
Example
Finance vs operating lease: a hospital takes an MRI machine on a seven-year finance lease covering most of its life. A company takes cars on a two-year operating lease, where the leasing firm handles maintenance and takes the cars back.
Exam tip
Other types: sale and leaseback, leveraged lease, and direct lease.
Topic 4
Tax and legal aspects of leasing
For tax, the lessor usually claims depreciation on the leased asset and the lessee claims the lease rentals as a business expense. Lease rentals also attract GST.
- Legal framework: Hire Purchase Act, 1972 (passed but never brought into force) — so HP is governed by the Indian Contract Act (bailment), Sale of Goods Act, Motor Vehicles Act (registration in the name of hirer with endorsement of financier); leasing by the Contract Act (bailment); stamp duty under state laws.
- Income tax: HP — hirer claims depreciation and the interest component; lessor in a finance lease (tax view) claims depreciation; lessee deducts lease rentals.
- GST: lease rentals are a supply of service at the rate applicable to the goods; HP is a supply of goods.
- Accounting: Ind AS 116 (lessees recognise right-of-use assets and lease liabilities), AS 19 for non-Ind AS entities.
- RBI guidelines: leasing and HP companies are NBFCs — must register with RBI (minimum net owned funds ₹10 crore for new NBFCs by 2027), follow prudential norms (income recognition, asset classification — NPA after 90 days, provisioning, capital adequacy 15%), fair practices code (transparent terms, no coercive recovery), scale-based regulation (2021) — base, middle, upper, top layers.
Example
Lease or buy: a firm compares buying a machine with a bank loan (claiming depreciation and interest) against leasing it (claiming the full rentals). The option with the lower present value of after-tax cash outflows is chosen.
Exam tip
Lease-or-buy decisions compare the present value of after-tax costs.
Topic 5
Origin and development of merchant banking
Merchant banking began with the merchant houses of Europe that financed trade. In India, Grindlays Bank started a merchant banking division in 1967, followed by Citibank and then SBI in 1972; SEBI later brought merchant bankers under regulation in 1992. Merchant banking is a fee-based service of managing and underwriting new issues, advising companies on raising capital, mergers, restructuring and project finance. SEBI (Merchant Bankers) Regulations, 1992 define a merchant banker as any person engaged in issue management by making arrangements for selling, buying or subscribing to securities, or acting as manager, consultant or adviser.
- 1
1967
Grindlays Bank started a merchant banking division
- 2
1969–1972
Citibank, SBI (1972) and ICICI (1973) followed
- 3
1980s
Growth with the boom in public issues
- 4
1992
SEBI regulations; CCI abolished — free pricing of issues
- 5
2000s
Book building, global depository receipts, M&A advisory
- 6
2020s
Record IPO activity; SME IPOs; QIPs and REITs
- Registration: SEBI-registered merchant bankers must meet minimum net worth and staffing norms; the 2024 amendments created two categories (Category I may handle main-board issues) with higher net-worth requirements.
Example
What a merchant banker does in an IPO: it advises on the issue size and timing, prepares the offer document, completes SEBI formalities, appoints the registrar and bankers, markets the issue to investors and manages the allotment.
Exam tip
List the functions: issue management, underwriting, project counselling, loan syndication, portfolio management and advising on mergers.
Topic 6
SEBI guidelines for merchant bankers
These guidelines protect investors by ensuring that only capable, honest firms manage public issues.
- SEBI (Merchant Bankers) Regulations, 1992 (amended 2024): registration, capital adequacy (minimum net worth), qualified staff, code of conduct, maintenance of books, half-yearly results, no underwriting beyond limits, due diligence certificates, disclosure of interests, no insider trading.
- SEBI (ICDR) Regulations, 2018: obligations of lead managers in public issues — due diligence, offer document disclosures, allocation, post-issue monitoring.
- Code of conduct: integrity, fairness, avoid conflicts of interest, maintain confidentiality, ensure investor grievance redressal.
Example
A compliance case: a merchant banker managing an IPO must carry out due diligence on the company's disclosures and file a due diligence certificate with SEBI. If misleading statements are later found in the offer document, SEBI can suspend or cancel its registration.
Exam tip
Key points: registration, minimum net worth, code of conduct, due diligence and penalties.
Topic 7
Venture capital: concept
Venture capital (VC) is long-term equity or equity-linked finance provided to new, innovative, high-risk, high-growth ventures, along with management support.
- Features: equity participation, high risk–high return, long-term (5–10 years), active involvement (board seats, mentoring), exit through IPO, trade sale or buy-back.
- 1
Seed
Proof of concept, prototype
- 2
Start-up / early stage
Product development and initial marketing
- 3
Second stage
Expansion of working capital
- 4
Expansion / growth
Scaling, new markets
- 5
Mezzanine / bridge
Pre-IPO financing
- 6
Buy-out
Management buy-out or buy-in
- 1
Deal origination
- 2
Screening
- 3
Evaluation and due diligence
Team, market, technology, financials
- 4
Deal structuring
Valuation, instrument (CCPS), term sheet
- 5
Post-investment monitoring and value addition
- 6
Exit
Example
A VC deal: two engineers have a prototype of an agri-drone but no collateral for a bank loan. A VC fund invests ₹3 crore for a 25% stake, joins the board and helps with hiring and customers. Five years later it exits by selling its stake when a larger company buys the start-up.
Exam tip
VC exits: IPO, trade sale, buy-back by promoters, or sale to another investor.
Topic 8
Venture capital guidelines and growth in India
Venture capital is now regulated by SEBI under the SEBI (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations, 2012, in which VC funds are Category I AIFs. Government support includes the Fund of Funds for Startups managed by SIDBI.
- Early phase: IDBI Venture Capital Fund (1986) after the Technology Development Fund; TDICI (ICICI and UTI, 1988) — later ICICI Ventures; RCTC, GVFL.
- Regulation: SEBI (Venture Capital Funds) Regulations, 1996 → replaced by SEBI (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations, 2012 (VCFs and angel funds under Category I AIF).
- Growth phase (2000s onwards): IT and internet boom; global VCs (Sequoia — now Peak XV, Accel, Tiger Global); India has the world's third-largest start-up ecosystem with over 100 unicorns.
- Government support: Startup India (2016), Fund of Funds for Startups (SIDBI, ₹10,000 crore), tax exemptions (Section 80-IAC), angel tax abolished (2024 Budget), SIDBI Venture Capital.
- Challenges: valuation corrections ("funding winter" 2022–23), exit options, regulatory uncertainty, concentration in a few cities and sectors.
Example
How VC grew: early VC in India was run by public institutions and funded mainly established technologies. After liberalisation and the IT boom, private domestic and foreign VC funds began backing start-ups in software, e-commerce and fintech.
Exam tip
Present the growth in phases: early (institutional), liberalisation, and the start-up era.
Key terms
- Credit rating
- Opinion on the ability to repay debt on time
- Finance lease
- Lease transferring risks and rewards to the lessee
- Merchant banker
- Issue manager and financial adviser registered with SEBI
- Due diligence
- Verification of facts disclosed in an offer document
- Venture capital
- Equity finance for high-risk, high-growth start-ups
Quick revision
- Rating symbols; CRAs — CRISIL, ICRA, CARE, India Ratings; rating process.
- Leasing types; lease vs buy; tax and GST aspects; Ind AS 116.
- Merchant banking history; SEBI MB and ICDR regulations.
- VC stages and process; SEBI AIF regulations; Startup India support.
Important exam questions
Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).
Short-answer questions
- Q1.State the objectives of credit rating.
- Q2.Name four CRAs in India.
- Q3.Distinguish finance and operating leases.
- Q4.What is a merchant banker?
- Q5.State two SEBI guidelines for merchant bankers.
- Q6.What are the stages of venture capital financing?
Long-answer questions
- Q1.Explain the concept of credit rating and the methodology of Indian CRAs.
- Q2.Explain leasing, its types and tax aspects.
- Q3.Explain the origin of merchant banking and SEBI guidelines.
- Q4.Explain venture capital and its development in India.
Stuck on this unit?
Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Management of Financial Services, or to ask about studying MBA at Synetic.
