Unit 1 of 4 · M.Com Sem 3

Unit 1: International accounting diversity and IFRS

International Accounting notes · PTU syllabus (MCOPAF311-18)

3 min read5 topics10 exam questions
On this page
  1. Unit summary
  2. Worldwide accounting diversity
  3. Causes of international differences
  4. International convergence of financial reporting
  5. IFRS: overview
  6. Nature and structure of the IASB and IFRS Foundation
  7. Key terms
  8. Quick revision
  9. Important questions

Unit summary

Accounting differs from country to country, which complicates global investment. This unit covers worldwide accounting diversity, the causes of international differences, international convergence of financial reporting, an overview of IFRS, and the nature and structure of the IASB and the IFRS Foundation.

After this unit you can

  • Explain the nature and consequences of worldwide accounting diversity
  • Identify the causes of international differences in accounting
  • Explain the process of international convergence
  • Describe IFRS and the structure of the IFRS Foundation and IASB

PTU syllabus topics

  • Worldwide accounting diversity
  • international convergence of financial reporting
  • causes of international differences
  • IFRS overview
  • nature and structure of the IASB/IFRSF
1

Topic 1

Worldwide accounting diversity

  • Countries historically differed in recognition (what is recorded — e.g., development costs), measurement (historical cost vs fair value, LIFO), presentation (formats) and disclosure (segment, related parties).
  • Consequences: costly multiple reporting for MNCs, difficulty comparing companies across borders, higher cost of capital, consolidation problems, lack of high-quality information in some markets.

Example

Daimler-Benz's 1993 NYSE listing showed a profit of DM 168 million under German GAAP but a loss of DM 949 million under US GAAP — a famous illustration of diversity.

2

Topic 2

Causes of international differences

Accounting differs between countries because of differences in legal systems, sources of finance, taxation, culture, inflation, political ties and the accounting profession.

ClassificationCauses of accounting diversity
Causes
  • Legal system

    Common law (case law, private standard setters — UK, USA) vs code law (statutory rules — Germany, France)

  • Providers of finance

    Equity markets (investor-oriented disclosure) vs banks/families (creditor- and tax-oriented)

  • Taxation

    Tax-driven accounting where tax and book figures must agree

  • Inflation

    Price-level accounting in high-inflation countries

  • Culture

    Gray's accounting values — professionalism vs statutory control, uniformity vs flexibility, conservatism vs optimism, secrecy vs transparency

  • Political and economic ties

    Colonial heritage, economic blocs

  • Level of development of the profession

  • Classification: Nobes' classification — micro-based (Anglo-Saxon) vs macro-uniform (continental European) systems.

Example

Finance shapes accounting: in the UK and US, companies raise money mainly from shareholders, so accounts focus on fair presentation for investors. In Germany, banks were the main lenders, so accounts were traditionally conservative to protect creditors.

Exam tip

Use Nobes's classification: equity-outsider (Anglo) vs credit-insider (Continental) systems.

3

Topic 3

International convergence of financial reporting

  • Harmonisation reduces differences; standardisation imposes uniform standards; convergence brings national standards into line with IFRS; adoption uses IFRS directly.
ProcessMilestones of convergence
  1. 1

    1973

    IASC formed by professional bodies of nine countries

  2. 2

    2001

    IASB replaces IASC

  3. 3

    2002

    Norwalk Agreement — FASB and IASB commit to convergence

  4. 4

    2005

    EU listed companies adopt IFRS

  5. 5

    2007

    SEC allows foreign private issuers to file IFRS statements without reconciliation

  6. 6

    2016

    India adopts Ind AS (IFRS-converged) in phases

  7. 7

    2021

    ISSB formed for sustainability standards

  • Status: IFRS required for most listed companies in over 140 jurisdictions; the USA still uses US GAAP for domestic issuers; India uses Ind AS with carve-outs; China uses converged standards.

Example

Convergence in practice: India did not adopt IFRS word for word; it converged through Ind AS, which follow IFRS with a few carve-outs. Many listed Indian companies with foreign investors now report on a basis comparable with global peers.

Exam tip

Distinguish adoption (using IFRS as issued) from convergence (aligning national standards with IFRS).

4

Topic 4

IFRS: overview

  • IFRS (International Financial Reporting Standards) include IFRS 1–18, older IAS 1–41 still in force, and IFRIC/SIC interpretations.
  • Conceptual Framework (2018): objective of financial reporting, qualitative characteristics, elements, recognition, measurement, presentation and disclosure, capital maintenance.
Key standardSubject
IAS 1 / IFRS 18Presentation of financial statements (IFRS 18 replaces IAS 1 from 2027)
IFRS 9Financial instruments
IFRS 15Revenue from contracts with customers
IFRS 16Leases
IFRS 10, 3, 11, 12Group accounting
IAS 21Foreign exchange
IFRS 13Fair value measurement
IFRS 17Insurance contracts

Example

IFRS in use: a company listed in London and Mumbai prepares one set of IFRS-based (Ind AS-converged) statements, so investors in both markets can compare it with global competitors without restating its accounts.

Exam tip

IFRS are principles-based — they rely on judgement rather than detailed rules.

5

Topic 5

Nature and structure of the IASB and IFRS Foundation

ClassificationStructure of the IFRS Foundation
IFRS Foundation
  • Monitoring Board

    Public authorities (IOSCO, SEC, EC, FSA Japan) — oversight of trustees

  • Trustees

    Governance, funding, appointments

  • International Accounting Standards Board (IASB)

    Develops IFRS Accounting Standards (14 members)

  • International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB)

    Develops IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards

  • IFRS Interpretations Committee

    Interprets standards

  • Advisory bodies

    IFRS Advisory Council, consultative groups

ProcessIASB due process
  1. 1

    Research and agenda

  2. 2

    Discussion paper

  3. 3

    Exposure draft with public comment

  4. 4

    Redeliberation

  5. 5

    Final IFRS issued

  6. 6

    Post-implementation review

Example

How a standard is made: the IASB publishes a discussion paper, then an exposure draft for public comment, reviews the responses and issues the final IFRS. The IFRS Interpretations Committee answers practical questions on applying standards.

Exam tip

Structure: Monitoring Board → IFRS Foundation Trustees → IASB and ISSB → interpretations committee and advisory council.

Key terms

Accounting diversity
Differences in accounting practices across countries
Convergence
Aligning national standards with IFRS
IFRS
International Financial Reporting Standards issued by the IASB
IFRS Foundation
Body overseeing the IASB and ISSB
Due process
Consultative procedure for developing standards

Quick revision

  • Diversity in recognition, measurement, presentation, disclosure.
  • Causes: legal system, finance providers, tax, inflation, culture (Gray), politics.
  • Convergence milestones: IASC 1973, IASB 2001, Norwalk 2002, EU 2005, Ind AS 2016.
  • IFRS = IFRS + IAS + interpretations; Conceptual Framework 2018.
  • IFRS Foundation: Monitoring Board, trustees, IASB, ISSB, Interpretations Committee.

Important exam questions

Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).

Short-answer questions

  1. Q1.What is accounting diversity?
  2. Q2.Distinguish common-law and code-law accounting systems.
  3. Q3.State Gray's accounting values.
  4. Q4.What was the Norwalk Agreement?
  5. Q5.What is the IASB?
  6. Q6.State the steps in the IASB due process.

Long-answer questions

  1. Q1.Explain worldwide accounting diversity and its consequences.
  2. Q2.Discuss the causes of international differences in accounting.
  3. Q3.Explain the process of international convergence of financial reporting.
  4. Q4.Describe IFRS and the structure of the IFRS Foundation and IASB.

Stuck on this unit?

Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with International Accounting, or to ask about studying M.Com at Synetic.

Planning your M.Com in Ludhiana? See the M.Com at SBS →

WhatsApp us