Unit 2: Industrial conflict & dispute settlement
Industrial Relations and Labour Laws notes · PTU syllabus (BBA 531-18)
On this page
Unit summary
When management and workers disagree, disputes arise. This unit covers the scope and manifestations of industrial conflict, legal provisions on strikes, lockouts, lay-off and retrenchment, and the machinery for settling disputes — conciliation, adjudication and arbitration.
After this unit you can
- Explain the causes and forms of industrial conflict
- Explain the legal provisions on strikes, lockouts, lay-off and retrenchment
- Describe the conciliation procedure
- Compare adjudication and arbitration
PTU syllabus topics
- Scope and manifestation of conflict
- provisions on strikes
- lockouts
- layoff and retrenchment
- concept and types of dispute settlement
- conciliation procedure
- adjudication and arbitration
Topic 1
Industrial conflict
An industrial dispute (Industrial Disputes Act, 1947) is any dispute between employers and workers connected with employment, non-employment, terms of employment or conditions of labour. Causes: wages and bonus, working conditions, retrenchment, discipline, union recognition, and political factors.
Strike
Workers stop work collectively
Lockout
Employer closes the workplace
Gherao
Workers surround managers
Go-slow and work-to-rule
Deliberately reduced output
Absenteeism and turnover
Unorganised conflict
Example
Forms of conflict: workers stop work together to press a demand (strike). The employer closes the workplace to press his terms (lock-out). Workers surround managers and do not let them leave (gherao). Workers stay at their places but work slowly (go-slow).
Exam tip
A strike is the workers' weapon; a lock-out is the employer's. Lay-off is temporary; retrenchment is permanent termination for surplus labour.
Topic 2
Strikes, lockouts, lay-off and retrenchment
| Term | Meaning and key rule |
|---|---|
| Strike | Cessation of work by workers acting together; in a public utility service, notice must be given within six weeks before striking, and the strike cannot begin within 14 days of giving notice |
| Lockout | Temporary closing of the workplace by the employer; in a public utility service the same notice rules apply |
| Lay-off | Temporary inability to give work (shortage of power, raw material); compensation of 50% of wages |
| Retrenchment | Termination of surplus workers; one month's notice and 15 days' wages per year of service; last come, first go |
Illegal strikes and lockouts are those in breach of notice rules or during pending proceedings.
Example
Lay-off compensation: a worker's basic wage plus dearness allowance is ₹600 a day. The factory lays her off for 10 working days because of a power shortage. Compensation is 50% of basic wage + DA for each day of lay-off: ₹600 × 50% × 10 = ₹3,000.
Example
Retrenchment compensation: a worker with 8 completed years of continuous service earns an average of ₹700 a day. Compensation is 15 days' average pay for every completed year: 15 × ₹700 × 8 = ₹84,000, plus one month's notice in writing (or a month's wages in place of notice). By the "last come, first go" rule, a worker who joined later is normally retrenched first in the same category.
Exam tip
Exam tip: "strike vs lockout" and "lay-off vs retrenchment" are classic short questions. Answer in a two-column table: who acts, temporary or permanent, and what compensation is due.
Topic 3
Machinery for dispute settlement
Under the Industrial Disputes Act, conciliation is attempted before reference to adjudication
- 1Bipartite negotiation
Collective bargaining
- 2Conciliation
Conciliation officer or board helps parties agree
- 3Court of inquiry
Investigates and reports
- 4Voluntary arbitration
An arbitrator chosen by both parties decides
- 5Adjudication
Labour court, industrial tribunal, national tribunal
Conciliation procedure: the conciliation officer holds meetings, tries to bring the parties to a settlement and, if successful, a settlement is signed; if not, a failure report is sent to the government, which may refer the dispute to adjudication.
Example
How one dispute moves through the machinery: a union demands a 15% bonus and management offers 8.33%. Direct talks fail, so the conciliation officer calls joint meetings. If both sides agree on, say, 12%, a settlement is signed and binds them. If not, the officer sends a failure report, and the government may refer the dispute to a labour court or industrial tribunal, whose award is binding.
Exam tip
Exam tip: in "machinery for settlement of disputes", go in order — negotiation, conciliation, court of inquiry, voluntary arbitration, adjudication — and say for each who decides and whether the outcome is binding.
Topic 4
Adjudication vs arbitration
Both settle an industrial dispute through the decision of a third party, when negotiation and conciliation have failed. Arbitration is voluntary: both parties agree to refer the dispute to an arbitrator. Adjudication is compulsory: the government refers the dispute to a labour court or tribunal.
Referred by
Government (compulsory)
Both parties voluntarily
Decided by
Labour court or tribunal
Arbitrator chosen by the parties
Nature
Judicial, binding award
Binding award, less formal
Speed
Slower
Usually faster
Example
A wage dispute: if the union and management sign an agreement to accept the decision of a retired judge, that is voluntary arbitration under Section 10A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. If they cannot agree and the government refers the dispute to an Industrial Tribunal, that is adjudication, and the award is binding.
Key terms
- Industrial dispute
- A dispute between employers and workers about employment
- Lockout
- Closing the workplace by an employer
- Retrenchment
- Termination of surplus workers
- Conciliation
- A third party helping disputing parties agree
- Adjudication
- Compulsory settlement by labour courts or tribunals
Quick revision
- Forms: strike, lockout, gherao, go-slow, absenteeism.
- Lay-off compensation 50%; retrenchment 15 days' wages per year of service.
- Machinery: negotiation → conciliation → arbitration → adjudication.
- Adjudication compulsory; arbitration voluntary.
Important exam questions
Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).
Short-answer questions
- Q1.Define an industrial dispute.
- Q2.Differentiate between a strike and a lockout.
- Q3.Differentiate between lay-off and retrenchment.
- Q4.What is conciliation?
- Q5.Differentiate between adjudication and arbitration.
Long-answer questions
- Q1.Explain the causes and forms of industrial conflict.
- Q2.Explain the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act on strikes, lockouts, lay-off and retrenchment.
- Q3.Explain the machinery for settlement of industrial disputes in India.
Stuck on this unit?
Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Industrial Relations and Labour Laws, or to ask about studying BBA at Synetic.
