Unit 2: Impact of change & resistance
Organisation Change and Development notes · PTU syllabus (BBA 532-18)
On this page
Unit summary
Change affects people operationally, psychologically and socially, and they often resist it. This unit covers the effects of change, reactions to change, reasons for resistance, methods of minimising it, and strategies of change.
After this unit you can
- Explain the operational, psychological and social effects of change
- Describe reactions to change
- Explain individual and organisational reasons for resistance
- Apply methods and strategies to minimise resistance
PTU syllabus topics
- Operational
- psychological and social effects of change on people
- reactions to change — acceptance
- indifference
- organised resistance
- frustration and aggression
- reasons for and methods of minimising resistance
- strategies of change
Topic 1
Effects of change on people
- Operational: new tasks, methods, skills and schedules.
- Psychological: uncertainty, anxiety, loss of control or status.
- Social: changed work groups, relationships and informal networks.
Example
One transfer, three effects: an employee moved to a new department must learn new tasks (operational), worries whether he can cope (psychological) and loses daily contact with old colleagues (social).
Topic 2
Reactions to change
People rarely accept change at once. Reactions range from enthusiastic acceptance to open resistance, and one person's reaction changes over time, typically from shock and denial to acceptance.
Support and communication shorten the dip and speed recovery
- 1Acceptance
Enthusiastic or cooperative
- 2Indifference
Passive, little interest
- 3Passive resistance
Delays, minimal compliance
- 4Organised resistance
Protests, union action
- 5Frustration and aggression
Sabotage, quitting
Example
A new attendance app: on the day it is announced, staff are surprised (shock). Some say "the old register worked fine" (denial) and complain to supervisors (anger). After training and a few weeks of use, most find it saves time (acceptance), and a few start suggesting improvements (commitment).
Topic 3
Reasons for resistance
Resistance to change has two sources. Individual resistance comes from habit, fear and insecurity. Organisational resistance comes from structure, group norms and threats to existing power or resources.
Causes
Habit, fear of the unknown, economic insecurity, loss of status, selective perception
Structural inertia, group norms, threat to expertise or power, resource allocations, limited focus of change
Example
ERP in a family firm: the accountant fears the new software will make his skills obsolete (individual: economic insecurity). The purchase department resists because the system will make all its rates visible to the head office (organisational: threat to established power).
Exam tip
Group the causes under individual and organisational headings. Then link each cause to a remedy, such as communication, participation or training.
Topic 4
Minimising resistance and strategies of change
Education and communication
Explain why change is needed
Participation and involvement
Involve people in planning
Facilitation and support
Training, counselling
Negotiation and agreement
Offer incentives
Manipulation and co-optation
Give resisters a role
Explicit and implicit coercion
Last resort
Strategies of change (Chin and Benne):
- Empirical-rational: people change when shown it is in their interest (information, evidence).
- Normative-re-educative: change by changing norms and values through involvement and learning.
- Power-coercive: change imposed using authority and sanctions.
Example
Kotter and Schlesinger's methods: staff resist a new shift system. Management explains the reasons (education and communication), asks a staff committee to design the rota (participation), offers transport for the night shift (facilitation and support) and agrees a shift allowance with the union (negotiation).
Exam tip
Participation gives the most lasting acceptance, but takes the most time.
Key terms
- Resistance to change
- Opposition to a proposed change
- Structural inertia
- Built-in mechanisms that keep the status quo
- Co-optation
- Giving resisters a role in the change
- Normative-re-educative strategy
- Changing norms through involvement
- Power-coercive strategy
- Using authority to impose change
Quick revision
- Effects: operational, psychological, social.
- Reactions: acceptance → indifference → resistance → aggression.
- Kotter-Schlesinger: education, participation, facilitation, negotiation, co-optation, coercion.
- Chin-Benne: empirical-rational, normative-re-educative, power-coercive.
Important exam questions
Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).
Short-answer questions
- Q1.State the psychological effects of change.
- Q2.List four individual reasons for resisting change.
- Q3.What is structural inertia?
- Q4.Name three methods of reducing resistance.
- Q5.What is the empirical-rational strategy?
Long-answer questions
- Q1.Explain the effects of change on people and their reactions.
- Q2.Explain the reasons for resistance to change and the methods of minimising it.
- Q3.Explain the strategies of change.
Stuck on this unit?
Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Organisation Change and Development, or to ask about studying BBA at Synetic.
