Unit 4 of 4 · B.Com Sem 1

Unit 4: Staffing, motivation & control

Business Organization and Management notes · PTU syllabus (BCOM 101-18)

3 min read4 topics13 exam questions
On this page
  1. Unit summary
  2. Recruitment and selection
  3. Motivation
  4. Function and process of control
  5. Span of control
  6. Key terms
  7. Quick revision
  8. Important questions

Unit summary

People make the organisation work, and control keeps it on course. This unit covers recruitment and selection, motivation theories of Maslow, Herzberg and Vroom, the function and process of control, and span of control.

After this unit you can

  • Explain recruitment and selection
  • Explain Maslow's, Herzberg's and Vroom's theories of motivation
  • Explain the function, process and types of control
  • Explain span of control and the factors that decide it

PTU syllabus topics

  • Recruitment and selection
  • motivation theories (Maslow, Herzberg, Vroom)
  • function and process of control
  • span of control
1

Topic 1

Recruitment and selection

Recruitment is searching for candidates and encouraging them to apply. Selection is choosing the most suitable among them.

CycleStaffing function
Staffing function
1Manpower planning
2Recruitment
3Selection
4Placement and orientation
5Training and development
6Appraisal and promotion
7Compensation
ComparisonRecruitment vs selection
Recruitment
Selection

Meaning

Searching for and attracting candidates

Choosing the right candidates from them

Nature

Positive — attracts many

Negative — rejects unsuitable

Aim

Create a pool

Pick best fit

Output

Applications

Appointment

ClassificationSources of recruitment
Recruitment
  • Internal sources

    Promotion, transfer, job posting, referrals

  • External sources

    Advertising, campus recruitment, employment exchanges, agencies, walk-ins, job portals, social media

ComparisonInternal vs external recruitment
Internal
External

Advantage

Cheap, motivates staff, known quality

Fresh ideas, wider choice

Limitation

Limited choice, internal politics

Costly, morale issue for existing staff

ProcessSelection process
  1. 1

    Preliminary screening of applications

  2. 2

    Application blank

  3. 3

    Employment tests

    Aptitude, intelligence, personality, trade

  4. 4

    Interviews

    Structured or panel

  5. 5

    Reference and background check

  6. 6

    Medical examination

  7. 7

    Final selection and offer

  8. 8

    Placement and induction

Key termsTypes of selection tests and interviews
Aptitude test
Potential to learn
Intelligence test
Mental ability
Personality test
Traits
Trade test
Skill on the job
Structured interview
Fixed questions
Stress interview
Pressure to test reaction
Panel interview
Several interviewers
Behavioural interview
Past behaviour as predictor

Example

Filling a clerk's post: the bank advertises and receives 500 applications (recruitment, a positive process of attracting candidates). A test, interview and document check reduce them to 5 appointments (selection, a negative process of elimination).

2

Topic 2

Motivation

Motivation is the process of stimulating people to act to accomplish goals; it is the willingness to exert effort towards organisational goals to satisfy a need.

ProcessMotivation process
  1. 1Unsatisfied need
  2. 2Tension and drive
  3. 3Search behaviour
  4. 4Need satisfied
  5. 5Reduction of tension
ClassificationClassification of motivation theories
Theories
  • Content theories

    What motivates — Maslow, Herzberg, McClelland, Alderfer, McGregor

  • Process theories

    How people are motivated — Vroom, Adams, Porter and Lawler, Locke

  • Reinforcement

    Skinner

Maslow's hierarchy of needs

HierarchyMaslow's hierarchy of needs (top = highest)
  1. Self-actualisation

    Growth and fulfilment, creativity

  2. Esteem

    Recognition, status, respect

  3. Social (belonging)

    Friendship, love, group

  4. Safety

    Job security, health, savings

  5. Physiological

    Food, water, shelter, pay

  • A satisfied need no longer motivates; people move up the hierarchy.

Herzberg's two-factor theory

ComparisonHerzberg's two factors
Hygiene factors
Motivators

Nature

Extrinsic — context of work

Intrinsic — content of work

Examples

Salary, policy, supervision, working conditions, job security

Achievement, recognition, work itself, responsibility, advancement

If absent

Dissatisfaction

No satisfaction (but no dissatisfaction)

If present

No dissatisfaction only

Motivation and satisfaction

McGregor's Theory X and Theory Y

ComparisonMcGregor's Theory X and Theory Y
Theory X
Theory Y

View of people

Dislike work, avoid responsibility

Like work, seek responsibility

Management style

Authoritarian, close control

Participative, empowering

Motivation

Fear and money

Achievement and growth

Vroom's expectancy theory (process theory)

Key formulasVroom's expectancy model
  • Motivation (force)

    F = E × I × V

  • Expectancy (E)

    Effort will lead to performance

  • Instrumentality (I)

    Performance will lead to reward

  • Valence (V)

    Value of the reward

  • Rule

    If any factor is zero, motivation is zero

ProcessVroom's logic
  1. 1Effort
  2. 2Performance (expectancy)
  3. 3Reward (instrumentality)
  4. 4Satisfaction of need (valence)

Other theories

ComparisonMcClelland, Alderfer and Adams
Idea
Application

McClelland — achievement, power and affiliation needs

Learned needs; achievers like feedback

Match jobs to need

Alderfer's ERG

Existence, relatedness, growth — can regress

Frustration–regression

Adams' equity theory

People compare their input–outcome ratio with others

Fair pay and treatment

ComparisonFinancial vs non-financial motivation
Financial
Non-financial

Examples

Pay, bonus, incentives, ESOP, commission

Recognition, job enrichment, participation, security, career

Effect

Quick

Lasting

ComparisonMaslow vs Herzberg
Maslow
Herzberg

Basis

Five needs in hierarchy

Hygiene and motivators

Link

Physiological, safety → hygiene

Esteem and self-actualisation → motivators

Criticism

Needs not strictly ordered

Based on engineers and accountants only

Example

Maslow and Herzberg at work: a salary that covers rent meets physiological needs; a permanent job, safety; a friendly team, social needs; a promotion, esteem. In Herzberg's terms, salary and working conditions are hygiene factors that prevent dissatisfaction, while recognition and challenging work are motivators.

3

Topic 3

Function and process of control

Controlling is the process of measuring performance, comparing it with standards and taking corrective action.

ProcessControl process
  1. 1

    Set standards

    Quantity, quality, cost, time

  2. 2

    Measure actual performance

  3. 3

    Compare with standards

  4. 4

    Analyse deviations

  5. 5

    Take corrective action

  6. 6

    Feedback and revise

Key termsFeatures and importance of control
Forward-looking
Corrects future performance
Continuous
Never-ending
Pervasive
At all levels
Linked with planning
Plans give the standards
Importance
Accomplishes goals, judges standards, improves efficiency, discipline, coordination
ComparisonPlanning vs control
Planning
Control

Time

Looks ahead

Looks back to correct

Nature

Creative

Corrective

Relation

Control needs plans

Plans need control — "twin functions"

Types of control

ComparisonFeedforward, concurrent and feedback control
Timing
Example

Feedforward (preventive)

Before activity

Inspection of raw material, budgets

Concurrent

During activity

Supervision, machine monitoring

Feedback

After activity

Financial statements, audit

ComparisonDirect vs preventive control
Direct control
Preventive control

Idea

Correct deviations by looking at results and managers

Prevent deviations by improving managers' quality

Method

Reports and comparisons, intervention

Selecting, training and appraising managers

Assumption

Managers make mistakes

Qualified managers make fewer mistakes

Timing

After the event

Before the event

Key termsControl techniques
Budgetary control
Plans in numbers
Break-even analysis
Output at no profit no loss
Ratio analysis
Financial health
Management audit
Review of management
MIS
Information systems
PERT/CPM
Time and project control
Statistical quality control
Control charts
Balanced scorecard
Financial, customer, process, learning measures
GraphStatistical quality control chart
MeasurementSample number (time)OUCLCentre lineLCLOut of controlMeasurement

A point beyond the control limits signals a deviation that needs corrective action

ProcessCharacteristics of an effective control system
  1. 1

    Suitable to the activity

  2. 2

    Timely and accurate

  3. 3

    Economical

  4. 4

    Flexible

  5. 5

    Understandable

  6. 6

    Acceptable to people

  7. 7

    Focused on critical points

  8. 8

    Corrective

Example

The control process: the standard is 500 units a day (set standards). Actual output is 440 (measure). The shortfall is 60 units (compare). The cause is a machine breakdown, so maintenance is rescheduled (corrective action).

Exam tip

Planning looks ahead; controlling looks back. Without plans there is nothing to control against.

4

Topic 4

Span of control

Span of control (span of management) is the number of subordinates who report directly to one manager.

ComparisonNarrow vs wide span
Narrow span
Wide span

Subordinates

Few (3 to 5)

Many (10 or more)

Hierarchy

Tall — many levels

Flat — few levels

Supervision

Close, detailed

Loose, more autonomy

Communication

Slow, distorted over many levels

Faster

Cost

High — many managers

Low

GraphSpan of control and number of levels
Levels of management neededSpan of control (subordinates per manager)OLevels needed for 1,000 workers

A wider span reduces the number of management levels, but beyond a point supervision weakens

Key formulasGraicunas' relationships
  • Direct single relationships

    n

  • Direct group relationships

    n × (2^(n−1) − 1)

  • Cross relationships

    n × (n − 1)

  • Total relationships

    n × [2^(n−1) + n − 1]

Example

A manager with 4 subordinates has 4 × (8 + 3) = 44 relationships; with 5 subordinates, 5 × (16 + 4) = 100 — complexity rises sharply.

Key termsFactors deciding span of control
Nature of work
Routine work allows wider span
Ability of manager and subordinates
Capable people need less supervision
Capacity to delegate
More delegation, wider span
Clarity of plans and standards
Clear goals reduce supervision
Communication and control techniques
Good systems allow wider span
Geographical spread
Dispersed units narrow span
Level in hierarchy
Top managers have narrower span
Similarity of tasks
Similar tasks allow wider span
ClassificationSpan of control and organisation shape
Organisation shape
  • Tall structure

    Narrow span, many levels, close control

  • Flat structure

    Wide span, few levels, quicker decisions

  • Modern trend

    Flatter structures with empowered teams

Key termsIdeal span
Classical view
Ideal 6 for top levels (Urwick), 8–12 for supervisory
Contingency view
No fixed figure — depends on the factors above

Key terms

Recruitment
Attracting candidates for jobs
Selection
Choosing the best candidate
Hygiene factors
Factors that prevent dissatisfaction (Herzberg)
Expectancy
Belief that effort will result in performance (Vroom)
Controlling
Measuring performance and correcting deviations
Span of control
Number of subordinates reporting to one manager
Tall structure
Narrow span with many levels

Quick revision

  • Recruitment attracts, selection chooses; selection steps from screening to induction.
  • Maslow: five needs; Herzberg: hygiene vs motivators; Vroom: F = E × I × V.
  • Control: set standards → measure → compare → correct; feedforward, concurrent, feedback.
  • Span of control: narrow (tall) vs wide (flat); depends on work, ability, delegation, distance.

Important exam questions

Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).

Short-answer questions

  1. Q1.Distinguish recruitment and selection.
  2. Q2.List the steps in selection.
  3. Q3.State Maslow's hierarchy of needs.
  4. Q4.What are hygiene factors?
  5. Q5.State Vroom's expectancy formula.
  6. Q6.Define controlling. State its steps.
  7. Q7.Differentiate feedforward and feedback control.
  8. Q8.What is span of control?
  9. Q9.Name four factors affecting span of control.

Long-answer questions

  1. Q1.Explain the process of recruitment and selection.
  2. Q2.Explain Maslow's, Herzberg's and Vroom's theories of motivation.
  3. Q3.Explain the function, process and types of control.
  4. Q4.Explain span of control and the factors determining it.

Stuck on this unit?

Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Business Organization and Management, or to ask about studying B.Com at Synetic.

WhatsApp us