Unit 2: Indemnity, guarantee, agency & partnership
Mercantile Law notes · PTU syllabus (BCOM 302-18)
On this page
Unit summary
Some contracts are so common in business that the law gives them special rules. This unit covers indemnity and guarantee, bailment and pledge, and agency under the Indian Contract Act, and the Indian Partnership Act, 1932 — admission, retirement and death of a partner and dissolution of a firm.
After this unit you can
- Distinguish indemnity and guarantee and explain the rights of a surety
- Explain bailment and pledge and the duties and rights of the bailee and pawnee
- Explain creation, kinds and termination of agency
- Explain admission, retirement and death of partners and dissolution of a firm
PTU syllabus topics
- Law of indemnity and guarantee
- law of bailment and pledge
- law of agency
- Partnership Act — admission
- retirement and death of a partner
- dissolution of a partnership firm
Topic 1
Indemnity and guarantee
- Contract of indemnity (Section 124): one party promises to save the other from loss caused by the conduct of the promisor or any other person. Parties: indemnifier and indemnity holder. Rights of indemnity holder (Section 125): recover damages, costs of suits, sums paid in compromise.
- Contract of guarantee (Section 126): to perform the promise or discharge the liability of a third person in case of default. Parties: surety, principal debtor, creditor.
Parties
Two
Three
Number of contracts
One
Three
Liability
Primary
Secondary (on default)
Purpose
Compensate loss
Secure a debt or performance
Right to sue third party
Indemnifier cannot sue in own name (generally)
Surety steps into creditor's shoes after payment
Kinds of guarantee
- Specific guarantee (single transaction) and continuing guarantee (series of transactions — Section 129), revocable for future transactions by notice or death of the surety.
Example
A continuing guarantee: a wholesaler agrees to supply goods on credit to a retailer up to ₹2 lakh at any time, and Gupta guarantees payment. This covers a series of transactions — a continuing guarantee (Section 129). If Gupta sends notice revoking it on 1 July, he remains liable for supplies made before 1 July but not for any supplied afterwards (Section 130).
Rights of the surety
- Against the principal debtor: subrogation (Section 140), indemnity (Section 145).
- Against the creditor: benefit of securities held by the creditor (Section 141).
- Against co-sureties: contribution in equal shares (Section 146).
Discharge of the surety
By revocation, variation in terms without consent (Section 133), release or discharge of the principal debtor, compounding or giving time to the debtor, loss of security by the creditor's act.
Topic 2
Bailment and pledge
- Bailment (Section 148): delivery of goods by one person (bailor) to another (bailee) for some purpose, on contract that they shall be returned or disposed of as directed when the purpose is accomplished. Example: giving a watch for repair, a car for parking.
- Duties of bailee: take reasonable care (Section 151), not make unauthorised use, not mix goods, return goods, return accretions.
- Rights of bailee: compensation for defects, reimbursement of expenses, particular lien (Section 170), sue third parties.
- Duties of bailor: disclose known faults, bear extraordinary expenses.
- Finder of goods is treated as a bailee.
- Pledge (Section 172): bailment of goods as security for payment of a debt or performance of a promise. Pawnor and pawnee.
- Rights of pawnee: retain goods (Section 173), extraordinary expenses, sue the pawnor, sell after reasonable notice if the pawnor defaults (Section 176).
Example
A tailor's lien: a customer gives cloth to a tailor to stitch a suit for ₹3,000. The tailor is a bailee and must take reasonable care of the cloth (Section 151). Once the suit is ready, he can hold it until his ₹3,000 is paid — a particular lien (Section 170) for the work done on those very goods, not for other unpaid bills.
Example
Pledge of gold: a shopkeeper pledges gold ornaments with a jeweller-financier for a loan of ₹1 lakh. If he fails to repay on time, the pawnee may sue for the debt or sell the gold after reasonable notice (Section 176). If the sale brings ₹1.2 lakh, the extra ₹20,000 (after expenses) must be paid back to the pawnor; if it brings only ₹90,000, the pawnor still owes ₹10,000.
Purpose
Any purpose (repair, safekeeping)
Security for a debt
Right to sell
Bailee cannot sell
Pawnee can sell after notice
Consideration
May be gratuitous
Always for consideration (the debt)
Use of goods
Only as agreed
Cannot use
Topic 3
Agency
Agent (Section 182): a person employed to do any act for another or to represent another in dealings with third persons. The person represented is the principal. "What a man does through another, he does himself" (qui facit per alium facit per se).
By express agreement
Written or oral (power of attorney)
By implied agreement
Conduct, estoppel, holding out
By necessity
Emergency — carrier selling perishable goods
By ratification
Principal later adopts an unauthorised act
By operation of law
Partners are agents of the firm
Kinds of agents
- General and special agents; mercantile agents — factor, broker, auctioneer, commission agent, del credere agent (guarantees payment by buyers); sub-agent and substituted agent.
Duties and rights
- Agent's duties: follow instructions and customs, reasonable skill and diligence, render accounts, not make secret profit, not deal on own account, communicate with principal.
- Agent's rights: remuneration, retainer, lien on principal's property, indemnity.
- Principal's liability: bound by acts within actual or apparent authority; liable for agent's misrepresentation and fraud in the course of business.
Example
Agency by ratification: the manager of a garment shop, without authority, buys a lot of winter jackets from a supplier in the owner's name. When the owner returns, he likes the stock and approves the deal. He has ratified the act (Section 196), so the contract binds him as if he had authorised it from the start — he must pay the supplier.
Exam tip
For agency answers, name the mode of creation (express, implied, necessity, estoppel or ratification), then state the agent's duties and the principal's liability to third parties — and quote Section 182 for the definition.
Termination of agency (Section 201)
By revocation by principal, renunciation by agent, completion of business, death or insanity, insolvency of principal, expiry of time, destruction of subject matter. Irrevocable agency — where the agent has an interest in the subject matter (Section 202).
Topic 4
The Indian Partnership Act, 1932
Partnership (Section 4): relation between persons who have agreed to share the profits of a business carried on by all or any of them acting for all. Essentials: agreement, business, sharing of profits, mutual agency (the true test — Cox v. Hickman, 1860).
Admission of a partner (Section 31)
- With the consent of all partners; a new partner is not liable for acts before admission unless agreed.
- A minor can be admitted only to the benefits (Section 30); on majority, must elect within six months to become a partner or not.
Retirement (Section 32)
- With consent of all, by express agreement, or by notice in a partnership at will.
- Retiring partner remains liable to third parties for acts until public notice of retirement is given; may carry on a competing business (subject to restraint agreements).
Death of a partner (Section 35)
- Dissolves the firm unless the contract provides otherwise; the estate of the deceased is not liable for acts after death; no public notice needed.
Dissolution of a firm (Sections 39–44)
By agreement (Section 40)
With consent of all partners
Compulsory (Section 41)
All but one insolvent; business becomes unlawful
On contingencies (Section 42)
Expiry of term, completion of venture, death, insolvency
By notice (Section 43)
Partnership at will
By the court (Section 44)
Insanity, permanent incapacity, misconduct, persistent breach, transfer of interest, perpetual losses, just and equitable
- Settlement of accounts (Section 48): losses paid first from profits, then capital, then by partners individually; assets applied to pay third-party debts, then partners' advances, then capital, and surplus shared in profit ratio.
Exam tip
Distinguish dissolution of partnership (relationship between partners changes, firm may continue) from dissolution of firm (business ends for all partners).
Example
Why public notice matters on retirement: Kapoor retires from a three-partner firm in March but no public notice is given. In May the firm buys goods worth ₹2 lakh on credit from a supplier who has dealt with the firm before and does not know of the retirement. If the firm fails to pay, the supplier can hold Kapoor liable as well. Had public notice been given, Kapoor would not be liable for debts incurred after it.
Exam tip
Admission needs the consent of all partners; a new partner is not liable for the firm's debts from before admission, and a retiring partner stays liable to third parties until public notice is given.
Key terms
- Indemnity
- A promise to save another from loss
- Surety
- The person who gives a guarantee
- Bailment
- Delivery of goods for a purpose, to be returned afterwards
- Del credere agent
- An agent who guarantees payment by buyers for extra commission
- Partnership at will
- A partnership with no fixed term, dissolvable by notice
Quick revision
- Indemnity two parties; guarantee three parties; surety's liability secondary.
- Bailee: reasonable care, particular lien; pawnee can sell after notice.
- Agency created by agreement, necessity, ratification, estoppel.
- Partnership: mutual agency is the true test; new partner needs consent of all.
- Dissolution: agreement, compulsory, contingency, notice, court.
Important exam questions
Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).
Short-answer questions
- Q1.Distinguish indemnity and guarantee.
- Q2.What is a continuing guarantee?
- Q3.Define bailment.
- Q4.What is agency by ratification?
- Q5.Who is a del credere agent?
- Q6.What is a partnership at will?
Long-answer questions
- Q1.Explain the rights and discharge of a surety.
- Q2.Explain the duties and rights of a bailee and a pawnee.
- Q3.Explain the creation and termination of agency and the duties of an agent.
- Q4.Explain the provisions relating to admission, retirement and death of a partner and dissolution of a firm.
Stuck on this unit?
Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Mercantile Law, or to ask about studying B.Com at Synetic.
