Unit 1: Business ethics foundations
Business Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility notes · PTU syllabus (MBA 106-18)
On this page
- Unit summary
- Meaning and characteristics of business ethics
- Principles and types of business ethics
- Importance of business ethics
- Myths about business ethics
- Ethical values and theories
- The main ethical theories
- Absolutism vs relativism
- Teleological and deontological approaches
- Kohlberg's stages of moral development
- Code of ethics
- Firm's relationship with stakeholders
- Key terms
- Quick revision
- Important questions
Unit summary
Business ethics gives managers a framework for deciding what is right when profit, law and conscience pull in different directions. This unit covers the characteristics, principles, types and importance of business ethics, common myths, ethical values and theories, absolutism vs relativism, teleological and deontological approaches, Kohlberg's stages of moral development, codes of ethics and the firm's relationship with its stakeholders.
After this unit you can
- Explain the characteristics, principles, types and importance of business ethics
- Identify and rebut common myths about business ethics
- Compare ethical theories, absolutism and relativism, and teleological and deontological approaches
- Explain Kohlberg's stages, codes of ethics and stakeholder relationships
PTU syllabus topics
- Characteristics
- principles
- types and importance of business ethics
- myths about business ethics
- ethical values and theories
- absolutism vs relativism
- teleological and deontological approaches
- Kohlberg's stages of moral development
- code of ethics
- firm's relationship with stakeholders
Topic 1
Meaning and characteristics of business ethics
Ethics is the study of moral principles that govern a person's behaviour. Business ethics applies these principles to business conduct — honesty, fairness, integrity and responsibility. Nature: based on moral values, relative to society and time, voluntary yet expected, and wider than law. Purpose: build trust, guide decisions, protect stakeholders and sustain long-term success.
Source
Moral values and conscience
Government and courts
Enforcement
Self and society
Penalties
Scope
Wider: what is right
Narrower: what is legal
Example
Not exaggerating product claims
Not selling expired goods
Characteristics
- Based on moral and social values; a code of conduct for business.
- Voluntary and self-disciplined, yet expected by society.
- Relative — standards differ across cultures and change over time.
- Protects all stakeholders, not only owners.
- An art and a science — principles applied through judgement.
Example
An ethical decision: a company could save costs by releasing untreated effluent at night without being caught. Business ethics asks whether it is right, not just whether it is legal or profitable.
Exam tip
Ethics applies moral principles to business decisions.
Topic 2
Principles and types of business ethics
- Principles: honesty, integrity, fairness, transparency, accountability, respect for others, promise-keeping, legal compliance, concern for stakeholders and the environment.
Personal ethics
Values of the individual manager
Professional ethics
Codes of a profession — CA, doctor, lawyer
Organisational ethics
Culture, policies and code of the firm
Functional ethics
Marketing, finance, HR, accounting, production
Societal and global ethics
Duties to community, environment and other countries
Example
Principles in practice: honesty: a seller discloses that a machine is refurbished. Fairness: all suppliers are paid on the same terms. Transparency: fees are stated up front. Accountability: the firm recalls a faulty batch at its own cost.
Topic 3
Importance of business ethics
- For the firm: reputation and brand value, customer loyalty, investor confidence, lower legal and regulatory risk, better employee morale and retention.
- For society: fair markets, consumer protection, environmental care, trust in institutions.
- For managers: a consistent basis for difficult decisions and defensible conduct.
Example
Satyam's ₹7,000-crore accounting fraud (2009) shows the cost of ignoring ethics — collapse of the share price, loss of clients and criminal prosecution of the promoters.
Topic 4
Myths about business ethics
Several common beliefs wrongly suggest that ethics has no place in business. Knowing why they are false is the starting point of the subject.
| Myth | Reality |
|---|---|
| Ethics is a personal matter, not a business one | Organisational culture and incentives shape individual conduct |
| Business and ethics do not mix | Ethical firms earn trust that sustains long-term profit |
| Ethics is only about obeying the law | Law is the minimum; ethics goes beyond it |
| Ethics cannot be managed | Codes, training, hotlines and leadership do change behaviour |
| Ethics is a fad or public relations | Investor ESG demands and regulation make it permanent |
| Ethical people need no guidance | Dilemmas are complex; even good people need frameworks |
Example
"Ethics costs money": a firm that cuts corners on product safety saves cost today but faces recalls, fines and lost customers later. Firms known for fair dealing find it easier to attract staff, investors and loyal customers.
Topic 5
Ethical values and theories
- Core ethical values: trustworthiness, respect, responsibility, fairness, caring and citizenship (Josephson's "six pillars of character").
Example
One decision, three lenses: should a firm close a loss-making plant? Utilitarian: does closure do more good than harm overall? Rights: were workers given notice and dues? Justice: are the burdens shared fairly between managers and workers?
Topic 6
The main ethical theories
Ethical theories give different tests for deciding what is right. Teleological theories judge an action by its results. Deontological theories judge it by duty and rules. Virtue ethics asks what a person of good character would do.
Teleological (consequentialist)
Utilitarianism — greatest good for the greatest number (Bentham, Mill); ethical egoism
Deontological (duty-based)
Kant's categorical imperative — act only on maxims you could will as universal; treat people as ends
Virtue ethics
Aristotle — character traits like honesty, courage, justice
Justice theory
Rawls — fairness, veil of ignorance, difference principle
Rights theory
Respect fundamental rights (life, privacy, free speech)
Indian ethos
Gita's nishkama karma, trusteeship (Gandhi)
Example
A defective product: a manager finds a minor defect that will affect 1 in 10,000 units. A utilitarian weighs the cost of a recall against the harm avoided. A Kantian says customers must be told, because hiding it treats them as a means. Virtue ethics asks what an honest manager would do.
Exam tip
Utilitarianism: Bentham and Mill. Duty ethics: Kant. Justice: Rawls. Virtue ethics: Aristotle.
Topic 7
Absolutism vs relativism
- Ethical absolutism: some moral rules are universal and unchanging — right everywhere and always (e.g., bribery and child labour are wrong in every country).
- Ethical relativism: what is right depends on culture, society or the individual — "when in Rome, do as the Romans do".
Standard
One universal standard
Varies by culture and situation
Strength
Consistency and clarity
Respects cultural difference
Weakness
Can be rigid and ignore context
Can justify any practice, e.g. bribes
Business use
Global codes of conduct
Local adaptation of customs and gifts
- Middle path: follow universal "hypernorms" (human rights, honesty) while allowing local variation in non-core matters — integrative social contracts theory (Donaldson and Dunfee).
Example
Gifts to officials: an absolutist says bribery is wrong everywhere. A relativist says customs differ, and what is a bribe in one country is a courtesy in another. Most multinational codes take the absolutist line on bribery and allow only small, declared gifts.
Topic 8
Teleological and deontological approaches
The teleological approach holds that an action is right if it produces good consequences. The deontological approach holds that some actions are right or wrong in themselves, whatever the consequences.
Focus
Consequences or ends
Duties, rules and intentions
Key test
Does the act produce the best outcome?
Is the act right in itself?
Thinkers
Bentham, Mill
Kant, Ross
Example
Lay off 100 to save 1,000 jobs
Never lie to customers, whatever the gain
Criticism
May sacrifice minorities
Rules may conflict; ignores outcomes
Example
Paying a bribe to win a contract that saves 500 jobs: the teleological view may justify it by the outcome. The deontological view rejects it, because bribery is wrong in itself and cannot be made a universal rule.
Topic 9
Kohlberg's stages of moral development
Most adults operate at the conventional level; ethical leaders aim for the post-conventional level
Lawrence Kohlberg described how moral reasoning matures through three levels with two stages each.
- Stage 6 Universal principles
Act on self-chosen principles of justice and rights
- Stage 5 Social contract
Laws serve welfare and can be changed
- Stage 4 Law and order
Duty, rules and social order
- Stage 3 Good boy or good girl
Seek approval, meet expectations
- Stage 2 Self-interest
What is in it for me; fair exchange
- Stage 1 Obedience and punishment
Avoid punishment
- Levels: pre-conventional (stages 1–2), conventional (stages 3–4), post-conventional (stages 5–6).
- Business relevance: most managers reason at the conventional level, so organisational rules, culture and leadership strongly shape behaviour.
- Criticism: Carol Gilligan argued it neglects an "ethics of care"; it measures reasoning, not actual behaviour.
Example
Why not pad an expense claim? Pre-conventional: "I might be caught." Conventional: "Company rules forbid it and colleagues would disapprove." Post-conventional: "It is dishonest, whether or not anyone finds out."
Exam tip
Three levels with two stages each: pre-conventional, conventional and post-conventional.
Topic 10
Code of ethics
- Meaning: a formal written statement of the values and standards of conduct expected of all employees.
- Contents: conflicts of interest, gifts and hospitality, confidentiality, insider information, fair dealing, harassment, environment, use of company assets, reporting violations.
- 1
Draft with employee input
- 2
Leadership endorsement
- 3
Communicate and train
- 4
Whistle-blower and helpline channels
- 5
Monitor and enforce consistently
- 6
Review periodically
Example
The Tata Code of Conduct (first issued in 1998) and Infosys's Code of Conduct and Ethics are widely cited Indian examples.
Topic 11
Firm's relationship with stakeholders
A stakeholder is any group that affects or is affected by the firm (R. Edward Freeman, 1984).
Shareholders
Fair returns, accurate disclosure
Employees
Fair pay, safety, dignity, growth
Customers
Safe products, honest information, fair prices
Suppliers
Fair terms, timely payment
Community
Jobs, local development, no pollution
Government
Pay taxes, obey laws
- Stakeholder mapping (Mendelow): power vs interest — manage closely, keep satisfied, keep informed, monitor.
Example
Stakeholders of a sugar mill: shareholders want dividends; employees want fair wages; farmers want prompt payment for cane; customers want quality; the community wants clean water; the government wants taxes and compliance. Management must balance these claims.
Key terms
- Business ethics
- Application of moral principles to business decisions
- Ethical relativism
- View that right and wrong depend on culture or situation
- Deontology
- Ethics based on duties and rules rather than outcomes
- Post-conventional level
- Kohlberg's level of reasoning from universal principles
- Stakeholder
- Group that affects or is affected by the firm
Quick revision
- Characteristics: moral, voluntary, relative, stakeholder-oriented.
- Types: personal, professional, organisational, functional, societal.
- Myths vs reality: ethics is manageable and pays in the long run.
- Theories: utilitarian, Kantian, virtue, justice, rights; absolutism vs relativism.
- Kohlberg: 3 levels, 6 stages; code of ethics; stakeholder duties.
Important exam questions
Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).
Short-answer questions
- Q1.Define business ethics.
- Q2.State any four principles of business ethics.
- Q3.Distinguish absolutism and relativism.
- Q4.What is the deontological approach?
- Q5.Name Kohlberg's three levels of moral development.
- Q6.What is a code of ethics?
Long-answer questions
- Q1.Explain the characteristics, types and importance of business ethics.
- Q2.Discuss common myths about business ethics.
- Q3.Compare teleological and deontological theories with examples.
- Q4.Explain Kohlberg's stages of moral development and their relevance to managers.
Stuck on this unit?
Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Business Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility, or to ask about studying MBA at Synetic.
