Unit 4: Consumer decision making
Consumer Behaviour notes · PTU syllabus (MBA 921-18)
On this page
Unit summary
Marketers model how consumers decide and how new products spread. This unit covers the consumer decision process and models — Howard–Sheth, Nicosia and Engel–Blackwell–Kollat — the opinion leadership process and profile of opinion leaders, and diffusion of innovations and the adoption process.
After this unit you can
- Explain the consumer decision-making process
- Explain the Howard–Sheth, Nicosia and EBK models
- Explain the opinion leadership process and profile
- Explain diffusion of innovations and the adoption process
PTU syllabus topics
- Decision process and models (Howard Sheth, Nicosia, Engel-Blackwell-Kollat)
- opinion leadership process and profile
- diffusion of innovations and adoption process
Topic 1
The consumer decision process
The five stages are need recognition, information search, evaluation of alternatives, purchase decision and post-purchase behaviour. Consumers do not always pass through every stage — routine purchases skip most of them.
Involvement decides how many stages are used: routine buying skips search, high-value buying uses every stage
- 1Need recognition
Gap between actual and desired state
- 2Information search
Internal memory and external sources
- 3Evaluation of alternatives
Compare brands on attributes
- 4Purchase decision
Brand, store, quantity, timing, payment
- 5Post-purchase behaviour
Satisfaction, repeat purchase or cognitive dissonance
Cognitive dissonance is post-purchase doubt ("Did I make the right choice?"); marketers reduce it with reassurance, warranties and follow-up. Types of buying behaviour: complex (high involvement, big differences), dissonance-reducing, habitual and variety-seeking.
Example
Buying a smartphone: a student's phone breaks (need recognition), they watch reviews and ask friends (search), compare three models on camera, battery and price (evaluation), buy one during a sale (purchase), then feel doubtful when a newer model launches a week later (post-purchase dissonance).
Exam tip
Mention cognitive dissonance in the post-purchase stage and how marketers reduce it.
Topic 2
Nicosia model
The four fields are: (1) the firm's message reaches the consumer and forms an attitude; (2) the consumer searches and evaluates; (3) the act of purchase; and (4) feedback from consumption to both the firm and the consumer.
- Francesco Nicosia (1966) models the flow of communication between the firm and the consumer in four fields.
- 1Field 1
Firm's message (advertising) shapes consumer attitude
- 2Field 2
Search and evaluation of the product
- 3Field 3
Act of purchase (motivation leads to purchase)
- 4Field 4
Feedback — consumption experience to consumer and firm
- Strength: shows interaction between firm and consumer; weakness: focuses on new products and is hard to test empirically.
Example
The model as a cycle: a brand advertises a new juice (field 1), the consumer compares it with other juices (field 2), buys it (field 3) and then shares feedback that the brand uses to change its next campaign (field 4).
Exam tip
The Nicosia model emphasises communication between the firm and the consumer.
Topic 3
Howard–Sheth model
The model has four parts: inputs (stimuli — product, symbols, social), perceptual and learning constructs (internal processing), outputs (attention, comprehension, attitude, intention, purchase) and exogenous variables (culture, social class, financial status).
- John Howard and Jagdish Sheth (1969) explain brand choice under limited information.
Inputs (stimuli)
Significative (product), symbolic (advertising), social (family, groups)
Hypothetical constructs
Perceptual (attention, search, bias) and learning (motives, choice criteria, brand comprehension, attitude, confidence, intention)
Outputs
Attention, comprehension, attitude, intention, purchase
Exogenous variables
Importance of purchase, personality, social class, culture, time and financial pressure
- Problem-solving levels: extensive, limited and routinised response behaviour.
Example
Three levels of decision: buying a first car is extensive problem solving; buying a replacement car of a familiar type is limited problem solving; buying the usual brand of tea is routinised response behaviour — the Howard–Sheth model describes all three.
Exam tip
Draw the four blocks and name the three levels of problem solving.
Topic 4
Engel–Blackwell–Kollat model
The EBK/EBM model has stages of input (information from marketing and other sources), information processing, the decision process (problem recognition, search, evaluation, purchase, outcomes) and variables influencing the decision (environmental and individual differences).
- EBK (1968), later Engel–Blackwell–Miniard (EBM): a comprehensive model of the decision process.
- 1Problem recognition
- 2Search
Internal and external
- 3Alternative evaluation
- 4Choice (purchase)
- 5Outcomes
Satisfaction or dissonance, feedback
- Influences: information input (marketing and other stimuli), information processing (exposure, attention, comprehension, acceptance, retention), environmental influences (culture, class, family, situation) and individual differences (resources, motivation, knowledge, attitudes, personality).
Nicosia
Firm–consumer communication loop
Role of advertising and feedback
Howard–Sheth
Brand choice and learning
Levels of problem solving; inputs and constructs
EBK
Complete decision process
Information processing and environmental influences
Example
Applying EBM: a family buying a washing machine recognises a need, searches stores and websites, evaluates front-load vs top-load, buys, and later evaluates satisfaction. Income, family size and culture influence each stage.
Exam tip
EBM is the most comprehensive model — use it for a 'describe a consumer decision model' question.
Topic 5
Opinion leadership process and profile
Opinion leaders are usually more knowledgeable, more involved with the product category, more exposed to media, and similar in social status to those they influence. They can be both receivers and givers of information. Opinion leadership is the process by which one person (the opinion leader) informally influences the attitudes or actions of others (opinion seekers or receivers). Opinion leaders are credible, knowledgeable, socially active and often heavy users in their product category. Marketers target them with samples, previews and influencer programmes.
Role
Gives advice and information
Asks for advice
Knowledge
High in the category
Lower
Media use
Heavy, specialised
General
- Theories of the process: two-step flow (media → opinion leaders → followers), multi-step flow (information flows in many directions), interpersonal flow.
- Profile of opinion leaders: high product involvement and knowledge, heavy media exposure, innovativeness, social activity, similar social status to followers; market mavens know about many product categories.
- Digital opinion leaders: influencers, YouTubers, reviewers.
Example
An opinion leader: a tech-savvy colleague whom everyone asks before buying gadgets recommends a particular laptop. Several colleagues buy it. Brands now target such people, including social media influencers, to spread word of mouth.
Exam tip
Opinion leadership is category-specific — an expert on gadgets may not influence fashion choices.
Topic 6
Diffusion of innovations
Rogers identified five product characteristics that speed adoption: relative advantage, compatibility, complexity (simpler is faster), trialability and observability. Diffusion is the process by which an innovation spreads through a social system over time (Everett Rogers). Elements: the innovation, channels of communication, the social system and time. Product characteristics affecting diffusion: relative advantage, compatibility, complexity, trialability and observability.
Example
Why UPI spread fast: it offered clear relative advantage (instant, free transfers), compatibility with existing phones and bank accounts, low complexity (scan and pay), easy trialability (send ₹1) and high observability (QR codes in every shop).
Exam tip
Learn the five characteristics with one example each.
Topic 7
The adoption process
Adoption is an individual's decision to become a regular user of a new product. It moves through five stages, and people adopt at different times, which gives Rogers' five adopter categories.
Innovators 2.5%, early adopters 13.5%, early majority 34%, late majority 34%, laggards 16%. Adopters are classified by how early they take up a new product; innovators and early adopters are the opinion leaders
- 1Awareness
Learns of the innovation
- 2Interest
Seeks information
- 3Evaluation
Considers whether to try it
- 4Trial
Tries it on a small scale
- 5Adoption (or rejection)
Decides to use it regularly
Example
Adopter categories for electric scooters: innovators (2.5%) bought the first models; early adopters (13.5%) followed and influenced others; the early majority (34%) buy once charging points are common; the late majority (34%) buy when most neighbours have one; laggards (16%) switch last.
Exam tip
The percentages 2.5, 13.5, 34, 34 and 16 add up to 100.
Topic 8
Adopter categories and consumer innovators
- Innovators
2.5% — venturesome, risk-takers
- Early adopters
13.5% — respected opinion leaders
- Early majority
34% — deliberate
- Late majority
34% — sceptical
- Laggards
16% — traditional
Consumer innovators tend to be younger, better educated, higher income, more interested in the product category, more venturesome and heavier media users.
Example
Adopter categories for electric scooters: innovators were enthusiasts who bought early models despite range limits; early adopters were urban professionals who influenced others; the early and late majority bought as charging improved and prices fell; laggards still prefer petrol scooters.
Exam tip
Remember the percentages: 2.5, 13.5, 34, 34 and 16.
Key terms
- Routinised response behaviour
- Habitual buying with little search
- Nicosia model
- Model of firm–consumer communication in four fields
- EBK model
- Comprehensive model of the consumer decision process
- Two-step flow
- Media influence passing through opinion leaders
- Diffusion
- Spread of an innovation through a social system
Quick revision
- Decision process: need, search, evaluation, purchase, post-purchase.
- Nicosia (4 fields), Howard–Sheth (inputs, constructs, outputs; EPS, LPS, RRB), EBK (process and influences).
- Opinion leadership: two-step and multi-step flow; profile; influencers.
- Diffusion: innovation, channels, social system, time; product characteristics.
- Adoption stages; Rogers' adopter categories.
Important exam questions
Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).
Short-answer questions
- Q1.What is post-purchase dissonance?
- Q2.Name the four fields of the Nicosia model.
- Q3.What are hypothetical constructs in the Howard–Sheth model?
- Q4.What is the two-step flow of communication?
- Q5.State the product characteristics that affect diffusion.
- Q6.Name Rogers' adopter categories.
Long-answer questions
- Q1.Explain the consumer decision-making process.
- Q2.Explain the Howard–Sheth model of consumer behaviour.
- Q3.Compare the Nicosia and EBK models.
- Q4.Explain the diffusion of innovations and the adoption process.
Stuck on this unit?
Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Consumer Behaviour, or to ask about studying MBA at Synetic.
