Unit 4 of 4 · MBA Sem 4

Unit 4: Ethics in consulting

IT Consulting notes · PTU syllabus (MBA 945-18)

3 min read6 topics10 exam questions
On this page
  1. Unit summary
  2. Principles for ethical consulting
  3. Approaches to ethics
  4. Codes of ethics
  5. Unethical consultant behaviours
  6. Business and international business ethics
  7. Responsibility and accountability
  8. Key terms
  9. Quick revision
  10. Important questions

Unit summary

Consultants hold privileged access and influence, so ethics is central to their work. This unit covers principles of ethical consulting, approaches to ethics, codes of ethics, unethical consultant behaviours, business and international business ethics, and responsibility and accountability.

After this unit you can

  • Explain principles and approaches to ethical consulting
  • Explain codes of ethics for consultants
  • Identify unethical consultant behaviours
  • Explain business and international business ethics and accountability

PTU syllabus topics

  • Principles for ethical consulting
  • approaches to ethics
  • codes of ethics
  • unethical consultant behaviours
  • business and international business ethics
  • responsibility and accountability
1

Topic 1

Principles for ethical consulting

  • Integrity, objectivity and independence, confidentiality, competence, fairness in fees and billing, avoiding conflicts of interest, respect for client autonomy, honesty in reporting, responsibility to society.
2

Topic 2

Approaches to ethics

Ethical theories offer different tests of right action: consequences (teleological), duty (deontological) and character (virtue).

ClassificationEthical theories
Ethical theories
  • Teleological (consequentialist)

    Utilitarianism — greatest good for the greatest number (Bentham, Mill); ethical egoism

  • Deontological (duty-based)

    Kant's categorical imperative — act only on maxims you could will as universal; treat people as ends

  • Virtue ethics

    Aristotle — character traits like honesty, courage, justice

  • Justice theory

    Rawls — fairness, veil of ignorance, difference principle

  • Rights theory

    Respect fundamental rights (life, privacy, free speech)

  • Indian ethos

    Gita's nishkama karma, trusteeship (Gandhi)

Example

A consultant finds the client's preferred vendor is not the best: by consequences, recommending the better vendor serves the client's interest. By duty, the consultant owes honest advice. By virtue, an honest professional says so.

3

Topic 3

Codes of ethics

  • Professional bodies: ICMCI (International Council of Management Consulting Institutes), IMC USA, Institute of Management Consultants of India; ACM and IEEE codes for computing professionals; ISACA code for IT audit and governance.
  • Common provisions: serve the client's interests, disclose conflicts, protect confidential information, accept only competent work, agree fees in advance, avoid misleading claims, comply with law.
4

Topic 4

Unethical consultant behaviours

Consultants hold the client's trust and confidential information, which creates room for misconduct.

ClassificationUnethical behaviours
Unethical conduct
  • Overselling

    Promising what cannot be delivered

  • Padding hours and inflating bills

  • Conflict of interest

    Advising on vendors in which the consultant has a stake

  • Misuse of confidential information

    Using client data for other clients

  • Creating dependency

    Withholding knowledge to extend the engagement

  • Bait and switch

    Senior staff in the pitch, juniors on delivery

  • Plagiarism and IP misuse

  • Telling clients only what they want to hear

Example

Conflict of interest: a consultant recommends software from a vendor that pays him a commission, without telling the client. The ethical course is to disclose the relationship or decline the commission.

5

Topic 5

Business and international business ethics

  • Business ethics in IT: data privacy, cybersecurity, AI fairness and transparency, software licensing, honest representation of capabilities.
  • International issues: bribery and corruption (US FCPA, UK Bribery Act, India's Prevention of Corruption Act), cultural relativism vs universal standards, data transfer and localisation laws, labour standards in global delivery, sanctions compliance.
6

Topic 6

Responsibility and accountability

  • Responsibility: consultants are responsible for the quality, accuracy and honesty of their advice; clients for their decisions.
  • Accountability mechanisms: contracts and SLAs, professional indemnity insurance, audits, peer review, client feedback, regulatory oversight, disciplinary action by professional bodies.

Example

Consultancy failures in large audits and public projects worldwide have led to fines, bans and stricter independence rules for advisers.

Key terms

Conflict of interest
Personal interest that could bias professional judgement
Bait and switch
Pitching senior experts but delivering with juniors
FCPA
US law against bribery of foreign officials
Professional indemnity
Insurance against claims of negligent advice
Accountability
Being answerable for one's actions and advice

Quick revision

  • Ethical principles for consultants.
  • Utilitarian, deontological, virtue, justice, rights approaches.
  • Codes: ICMCI, IMC, ACM, IEEE, ISACA.
  • Unethical behaviours.
  • IT business ethics; international anti-bribery laws; responsibility and accountability mechanisms.

Important exam questions

Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).

Short-answer questions

  1. Q1.State four principles of ethical consulting.
  2. Q2.Distinguish utilitarian and deontological ethics.
  3. Q3.Name two professional codes for IT consultants.
  4. Q4.What is bait and switch?
  5. Q5.Name two international anti-bribery laws.
  6. Q6.State two accountability mechanisms for consultants.

Long-answer questions

  1. Q1.Explain the principles and approaches to ethical consulting.
  2. Q2.Discuss codes of ethics for consultants.
  3. Q3.Explain common unethical consultant behaviours and how to prevent them.
  4. Q4.Discuss business and international business ethics, responsibility and accountability in consulting.

Stuck on this unit?

Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with IT Consulting, or to ask about studying MBA at Synetic.

Planning your MBA in Ludhiana? See the MBA at SBS →

WhatsApp us