Unit 2 of 4 · M.Com Sem 3

Unit 2: Governance reform and business ethics

Corporate Governance, Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility notes · PTU syllabus (MCOP303-18)

4 min read7 topics10 exam questions
On this page
  1. Unit summary
  2. Corporate governance developments in India
  3. Legal and regulatory changes
  4. Definition and nature of business ethics
  5. Causes of unethical behaviour
  6. Ethics vs morality vs law
  7. Ethical theories
  8. Ethical dilemmas and codes of ethics
  9. Key terms
  10. Quick revision
  11. Important questions

Unit summary

India built its governance framework through committees and laws, and ethics underpins it all. This unit covers Indian governance developments — CII code, Kumar Mangalam Birla, Narayana Murthy, Naresh Chandra and J.J. Irani committees, legal and regulatory changes — and business ethics: definition and nature, causes of unethical behaviour, ethics vs morality vs law, ethical theories, ethical dilemmas and codes of ethics.

After this unit you can

  • Trace corporate governance reforms in India through committee reports
  • Explain legal and regulatory changes — Companies Act 2013 and SEBI LODR
  • Explain the nature of business ethics, causes of unethical behaviour and ethical theories
  • Explain ethical dilemmas and codes of ethics

PTU syllabus topics

  • Indian governance developments — CII
  • Kumaramangalam Birla
  • Narayana Murthy
  • Naresh Chandra and JJ Irani committee reports
  • legal and regulatory changes
  • definition and nature of ethics
  • causes of unethical behaviour
  • ethics vs morality vs law
  • ethical theories
  • ethical dilemmas
  • code of ethics
1

Topic 1

Corporate governance developments in India

Committee / codeYearKey recommendations
CII Desirable Corporate Governance Code1998Voluntary code — independent directors, audit committees, disclosures
Kumar Mangalam Birla Committee (SEBI)1999Clause 49 of the listing agreement — independent directors (one-third/half), audit committee, remuneration committee, MD&A, CG report
Naresh Chandra Committee2002Auditor–company relationship — auditor independence, rotation of audit partners, CEO/CFO certification
N.R. Narayana Murthy Committee (SEBI)2003Strengthened Clause 49 — audit committee role, whistle-blower policy, risk management, independent director definition
J.J. Irani Committee2005Basis for new Companies Act — independent directors, related-party transactions, class actions
Kotak Committee (SEBI)2017Separation of chairperson and MD/CEO for top companies, board diversity, enhanced disclosures

Example

From voluntary to mandatory: the CII code (1998) was voluntary; the Kumar Mangalam Birla Committee led to Clause 49 of the listing agreement (2000); the Kotak Committee (2017) strengthened board independence. Today, SEBI's LODR Regulations, 2015 make these rules binding on listed companies.

Exam tip

Learn the main committees in order with one recommendation each.

2

Topic 2

Legal and regulatory changes

  • Companies Act, 2013: independent directors (Section 149, Schedule IV), woman director, audit/nomination and remuneration/stakeholders' relationship/CSR committees, related-party transactions (Section 188), CSR (Section 135), class action suits (Section 245), rotation of auditors, secretarial audit, NFRA (Section 132).
  • SEBI (LODR) Regulations, 2015: board composition, committees, RPT approvals, disclosures, BRSR, vigil mechanism.
  • Other: SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations 2015, Stewardship Code for institutional investors (2019), proxy advisory regulation, IBC (2016).

Example

Rules in practice: a listed company must have at least one-third independent directors, a woman director, an audit committee with a majority of independent directors, and must spend 2% of average net profit on CSR if it meets the Section 135 thresholds.

Exam tip

Key sources: Companies Act, 2013 and SEBI (LODR) Regulations, 2015.

3

Topic 3

Definition and nature of business ethics

Ethics is the study of moral principles that govern a person's behaviour. Business ethics applies these principles to business conduct — honesty, fairness, integrity and responsibility. Nature: based on moral values, relative to society and time, voluntary yet expected, and wider than law. Purpose: build trust, guide decisions, protect stakeholders and sustain long-term success.

ComparisonEthics vs law
Ethics
Law

Source

Moral values and conscience

Government and courts

Enforcement

Self and society

Penalties

Scope

Wider: what is right

Narrower: what is legal

Example

Not exaggerating product claims

Not selling expired goods

Example

An ethical decision: a company can save costs by dumping effluent into a river at night without being caught. Business ethics asks whether it is right, not just whether it is legal or profitable — and the answer is no.

Exam tip

Business ethics applies moral principles to business decisions and conduct.

4

Topic 4

Causes of unethical behaviour

  • Individual factors: greed, personal values, low moral development (Kohlberg's stages), rationalisation.
  • Organisational factors: unrealistic targets, pressure from superiors, reward systems that ignore means, weak controls, toxic culture.
  • External factors: competition, weak enforcement, corruption, societal norms.
  • Rationalisations (Gellerman): "it's not really illegal", "it's in everyone's interest", "no one will find out", "the company will protect me".

Example

Pressure leads to wrongdoing: a sales team is given unrealistic targets and rewarded only on volume. Some employees start mis-selling insurance policies to elderly customers. The cause is partly individual, but mainly organisational — targets and culture.

Exam tip

Causes: individual (greed, values), organisational (pressure, culture, weak controls) and environmental (competition, weak regulation).

5

Topic 5

Ethics vs morality vs law

ComparisonEthics, morality and law
Source
Enforcement

Ethics

Systematic reasoning about right conduct (professional/organisational codes)

Self-regulation, professional bodies

Morality

Personal and cultural beliefs about right and wrong

Conscience, society

Law

Rules enacted by the state

Courts, penalties

  • Not everything legal is ethical (aggressive tax avoidance), and ethics often goes beyond legal minimums.

Example

Legal but unethical: charging a very high price for a life-saving medicine during an emergency may be legal, but many would consider it unethical. Ethics often demands more than the law requires.

Exam tip

Law is the minimum standard enforced by the state; ethics goes beyond it.

6

Topic 6

Ethical theories

ClassificationEthical theories
Ethical theories
  • Teleological (consequentialist)

    Utilitarianism — greatest good for the greatest number (Bentham, Mill); ethical egoism

  • Deontological (duty-based)

    Kant's categorical imperative — act only on maxims you could will as universal; treat people as ends

  • Virtue ethics

    Aristotle — character traits like honesty, courage, justice

  • Justice theory

    Rawls — fairness, veil of ignorance, difference principle

  • Rights theory

    Respect fundamental rights (life, privacy, free speech)

  • Indian ethos

    Gita's nishkama karma, trusteeship (Gandhi)

Example

Two theories, one decision: closing a plant saves the company money and protects 5,000 jobs elsewhere but costs 300 local jobs. Utilitarianism weighs total good and may support closure; a deontological (duty-based) view stresses obligations to the 300 workers, such as fair notice and support.

Exam tip

Teleological = judge by consequences; deontological = judge by duties and rules; virtue ethics = judge by character.

7

Topic 7

Ethical dilemmas and codes of ethics

  • Ethical dilemma: a situation where every option involves violating some ethical principle — e.g., reporting a friend's fraud, layoffs vs company survival, gifts from suppliers.
ProcessResolving an ethical dilemma
  1. 1

    Recognise the issue

  2. 2

    Get the facts

  3. 3

    Identify stakeholders and options

  4. 4

    Evaluate options

    Utilitarian, rights, justice, virtue tests; "newspaper test"

  5. 5

    Decide and act

  6. 6

    Reflect on the outcome

  • Code of ethics/conduct: written statement of values and expected behaviour — conflicts of interest, gifts, insider information, fair dealing, harassment, environment; supported by training, ethics officers, hotlines and enforcement.

Example

The Tata Code of Conduct (first issued in 1998) and Infosys's Code of Conduct and Ethics are widely cited Indian examples.

Key terms

Clause 49
Listing agreement clause on corporate governance (now SEBI LODR)
Independent director
Director without material relationship with the company
Business ethics
Application of ethical principles to business decisions
Utilitarianism
Ethics judged by the greatest good for the greatest number
Code of ethics
Written statement of values and conduct expected

Quick revision

  • CII 1998 → Birla 1999 (Clause 49) → Naresh Chandra 2002 → Murthy 2003 → Irani 2005 → Kotak 2017.
  • Companies Act 2013 and SEBI LODR 2015 provisions.
  • Causes of unethical behaviour: individual, organisational, external.
  • Ethics vs morality vs law.
  • Theories: utilitarian, Kantian, virtue, justice, rights; dilemma resolution; codes of ethics.

Important exam questions

Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).

Short-answer questions

  1. Q1.What was Clause 49?
  2. Q2.State two recommendations of the Narayana Murthy Committee.
  3. Q3.What is the Naresh Chandra Committee known for?
  4. Q4.Distinguish ethics and law.
  5. Q5.What is Kant's categorical imperative?
  6. Q6.What is an ethical dilemma?

Long-answer questions

  1. Q1.Trace the evolution of corporate governance in India through various committee reports.
  2. Q2.Explain the legal and regulatory changes in corporate governance under the Companies Act and SEBI LODR.
  3. Q3.Explain the causes of unethical behaviour and the relationship between ethics, morality and law.
  4. Q4.Explain ethical theories and how ethical dilemmas can be resolved.

Stuck on this unit?

Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Corporate Governance, Ethics and Corporate Social Responsibility, or to ask about studying M.Com at Synetic.

Planning your M.Com in Ludhiana? See the M.Com at SBS →

WhatsApp us