Unit 1 of 4 · M.Com Sem 1

Unit 1: The Indian Contract Act, 1872

Legal Aspects of Business notes · PTU syllabus (MCOP105-18)

8 min read7 topics10 exam questions
On this page
  1. Unit summary
  2. Agreement and kinds of contracts
  3. Offer and acceptance
  4. Capacity to contract
  5. Free consent, consideration and legality of object
  6. Performance, discharge and remedies for breach
  7. Indemnity and guarantee
  8. Agency
  9. Key terms
  10. Quick revision
  11. Important questions

Unit summary

The Indian Contract Act, 1872 is the base of all business law. This unit covers the essential elements of a valid contract, offer and acceptance, consideration, capacity, free consent, performance and discharge, breach and remedies, contracts of indemnity and guarantee, rights and liabilities of sureties, and the creation, classification and termination of agency.

After this unit you can

  • Explain the essentials of a valid contract, offer, acceptance and consideration
  • Explain capacity, free consent, discharge and remedies for breach
  • Explain indemnity, guarantee and the rights and liabilities of a surety
  • Explain the creation, kinds and termination of agency

PTU syllabus topics

  • Essential elements of a valid contract
  • offer and acceptance
  • consideration
  • capacity
  • free consent
  • performance and discharge
  • breach of contract and remedies
  • contracts of indemnity and guarantee
  • surety rights/liabilities
  • creation and classification of agency
  • principal-agent relationship and termination
1

Topic 1

Agreement and kinds of contracts

Section 2(h): a contract is an agreement enforceable by law. Section 2(e): every promise and every set of promises forming consideration for each other is an agreement. Hence Contract = Agreement + Enforceability; "all contracts are agreements but all agreements are not contracts" (social, domestic and moral agreements are not).

ClassificationEssentials of a valid contract (Section 10)
Valid contract
  • Offer and acceptance

  • Intention to create legal relations

    Balfour v. Balfour (1919) — domestic arrangement not a contract

  • Lawful consideration

  • Capacity of parties

  • Free consent

  • Lawful object

  • Not expressly declared void

  • Certainty and possibility of performance

  • Legal formalities where required

KindMeaningExample
ValidHas all essentials; enforceableSale of a car for ₹5 lakh
Void agreementNot enforceable from the startAgreement with a minor
Void contractValid when made, becomes unenforceable laterContract becomes illegal by a new law
VoidableEnforceable at the option of one partyConsent obtained by coercion
IllegalForbidden by law; collateral agreements also voidAgreement to smuggle goods
UnenforceableValid but cannot be enforced due to a technical defectUnstamped agreement
Contingent (Section 31)Performance depends on a future uncertain eventInsurance, indemnity
Quasi-contract (Sections 68–72)Obligation imposed by law without agreementMoney paid by mistake must be returned
Express / implied / executed / executoryBy formation and performanceBus ride (implied), sale on credit (executory)

Quasi-contracts

  • Supply of necessaries to a person incapable of contracting (Section 68).
  • Payment by an interested person (Section 69).
  • Obligation to pay for non-gratuitous act (Section 70).
  • Finder of goods (Section 71).
  • Money paid or goods delivered by mistake or coercion (Section 72).

Example

Agreement vs contract: promising a friend to go to a film together is an agreement but not a contract — there is no intention to create legal relations. Agreeing to sell a scooter for ₹40,000 is a contract because it is enforceable by law. All contracts are agreements, but not all agreements are contracts.

Exam tip

Kinds of contracts: valid, void, voidable, illegal, unenforceable; express, implied, quasi; executed and executory.

2

Topic 2

Offer and acceptance

  • Offer (Section 2(a)): signification of willingness to do or abstain from doing something with a view to obtaining the assent of the other.
  • Types: express or implied; specific or general offer (Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Co., 1893); cross offers; counter offer; standing offer.
  • Invitation to offer (price tags, catalogues, tenders, auctions) is not an offer — Pharmaceutical Society v. Boots (1953).
  • Rules of acceptance: absolute and unconditional, communicated to the offeror, in the prescribed or usual manner, within reasonable time, by the offeree, before the offer lapses; silence is not acceptance (Felthouse v. Bindley, 1862).
ProcessCommunication of offer and acceptance (Section 4)
  1. 1Offer complete

    When it comes to the knowledge of the offeree

  2. 2Acceptance complete against the proposer

    When put in course of transmission

  3. 3Acceptance complete against the acceptor

    When it comes to the knowledge of the proposer

  4. 4Revocation of offer

    Any time before acceptance is complete against the proposer

Exam tip

Lalman Shukla v. Gauri Dutt (1913): a person who finds a missing boy without knowing of the reward cannot claim it — acceptance requires knowledge of the offer.

Example

Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893): the company offered £100 to anyone who caught influenza after using its smoke ball as directed. Mrs Carlill used it, caught flu and claimed. The court held it was a general offer to the world, accepted by performing the conditions.

Exam tip

Acceptance must be absolute, unqualified and communicated; a counter-offer rejects the original offer.

3

Topic 3

Capacity to contract

Section 11: every person is competent who is of the age of majority (18), of sound mind (Section 12) and not disqualified by law.

  • Minor: agreement is void ab initio (Mohori Bibee v. Dharmodas Ghose, 1903); no ratification on attaining majority; no estoppel; minor can be a beneficiary/promisee; liable for necessaries out of their property (Section 68); can be admitted to the benefits of partnership.
  • Unsound mind: contracts during unsoundness void; lucid intervals allowed.
  • Disqualified persons: alien enemies, foreign sovereigns, convicts, insolvents.

Example

Mohori Bibee v Dharmodas Ghose (1903): a minor mortgaged his property for a loan. The Privy Council held that an agreement with a minor is void from the beginning, so the lender could not recover the money.

Exam tip

An agreement with a minor is void ab initio; a minor can be a beneficiary but cannot be bound.

4

Topic 4

Free consent, consideration and legality of object

Consent (Section 13): agreeing upon the same thing in the same sense (consensus ad idem). Free consent (Section 14): not caused by:

ClassificationFactors vitiating free consent
Free consent
  • Coercion (Section 15)

    Threat to commit an act forbidden by IPC/BNS or unlawful detention — voidable

  • Undue influence (Section 16)

    Domination of will by a person in a position of trust — voidable

  • Fraud (Section 17)

    Deliberate false representation — voidable + damages

  • Misrepresentation (Section 18)

    Innocent false statement — voidable

  • Mistake (Sections 20–22)

    Bilateral mistake of fact — void; mistake of law — no relief

Consideration

Section 2(d): when at the desire of the promisor, the promisee or any other person has done or abstained, or does or abstains, or promises to do or abstain from something, such act, abstinence or promise is consideration.

  • Must move at the desire of the promisor; may move from the promisee or any other person (Chinnaya v. Ramayya, 1882); may be past, present or future; need not be adequate; must be real and lawful.
  • "No consideration, no contract" (Section 25) — exceptions: natural love and affection (written and registered), compensation for past voluntary service, promise to pay a time-barred debt (written and signed), agency (Section 185), gifts actually made.

Legality of object (Sections 23–30)

The object or consideration is unlawful if it is forbidden by law, defeats any law, is fraudulent, injures person or property, or is immoral or opposed to public policy.

  • Expressly void agreements: in restraint of marriage (Section 26), restraint of trade (Section 27 — except sale of goodwill), restraint of legal proceedings (Section 28), uncertain agreements (Section 29), wagering agreements (Section 30), agreements to do impossible acts (Section 56).

Example

Consent obtained by misrepresentation: a seller honestly but wrongly says a used car has run 30,000 km when it has run 80,000 km. The buyer's consent is not free, so the contract is voidable at the buyer's option. If the seller knew the truth, it would be fraud.

Exam tip

Consent is not free when caused by coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation or mistake.

5

Topic 5

Performance, discharge and remedies for breach

  • Performance: actual performance or tender (offer to perform); by promisor, agent or legal representatives; joint promises — joint and several liability.
ClassificationModes of discharge of contracts
Discharge
  • By performance

    Actual or attempted (tender)

  • By mutual agreement

    Novation, rescission, alteration, remission, waiver

  • By impossibility

    Supervening impossibility — frustration (Taylor v. Caldwell, 1863)

  • By lapse of time

    Limitation Act, 1963

  • By operation of law

    Death, insolvency, merger

  • By breach

    Actual or anticipatory

Remedies for breach

  • Rescission: aggrieved party may cancel the contract (Section 39).
  • Damages (Section 73): ordinary (naturally arising), special (if contemplated by both — Hadley v. Baxendale, 1854), exemplary (breach of promise to marry, dishonour of cheque), nominal; remote damages not recoverable; duty to mitigate loss.
  • Liquidated damages and penalty (Section 74): reasonable compensation not exceeding the stipulated amount.
  • Quantum meruit: payment for work done.
  • Specific performance and injunction (Specific Relief Act, 1963).

Example

Damages for breach: a supplier fails to deliver 100 tonnes of steel at the agreed ₹50,000 per tonne, and the buyer has to buy at ₹53,000. The buyer can claim ₹3,000 × 100 = ₹3 lakh as damages. Remote losses, such as a lost unrelated contract, are not recoverable (Hadley v Baxendale).

Exam tip

Remedies: damages, specific performance, injunction, quantum meruit and rescission.

6

Topic 6

Indemnity and guarantee

  • Contract of indemnity (Section 124): one party promises to save the other from loss caused by the conduct of the promisor or any other person. Parties: indemnifier and indemnity holder. Rights of indemnity holder (Section 125): recover damages, costs of suits, sums paid in compromise.
  • Contract of guarantee (Section 126): to perform the promise or discharge the liability of a third person in case of default. Parties: surety, principal debtor, creditor.
ComparisonIndemnity vs guarantee
Indemnity
Guarantee

Parties

Two

Three

Number of contracts

One

Three

Liability

Primary

Secondary (on default)

Purpose

Compensate loss

Secure a debt or performance

Right to sue third party

Indemnifier cannot sue in own name (generally)

Surety steps into creditor's shoes after payment

Kinds of guarantee

  • Specific guarantee (single transaction) and continuing guarantee (series of transactions — Section 129), revocable for future transactions by notice or death of the surety.

Rights of the surety

  • Against the principal debtor: subrogation (Section 140), indemnity (Section 145).
  • Against the creditor: benefit of securities held by the creditor (Section 141).
  • Against co-sureties: contribution in equal shares (Section 146).

Discharge of the surety

By revocation, variation in terms without consent (Section 133), release or discharge of the principal debtor, compounding or giving time to the debtor, loss of security by the creditor's act.

Liabilities of the surety

  • Co-extensive with that of the principal debtor (Section 128) — the creditor may sue the surety without first suing the debtor.
  • Liability arises on the debtor's default; limited to the amount guaranteed.

Example

Guarantee: A takes a bank loan of ₹5 lakh and B guarantees repayment. If A defaults, B must pay. There are three parties — the debtor (A), creditor (bank) and surety (B) — whereas an indemnity contract has only two.

Exam tip

Indemnity: two parties, primary liability. Guarantee: three parties, secondary liability of the surety.

7

Topic 7

Agency

Agent (Section 182): a person employed to do any act for another or to represent another in dealings with third persons. The person represented is the principal. "What a man does through another, he does himself" (qui facit per alium facit per se).

ClassificationCreation of agency
Agency
  • By express agreement

    Written or oral (power of attorney)

  • By implied agreement

    Conduct, estoppel, holding out

  • By necessity

    Emergency — carrier selling perishable goods

  • By ratification

    Principal later adopts an unauthorised act

  • By operation of law

    Partners are agents of the firm

Kinds of agents

  • General and special agents; mercantile agents — factor, broker, auctioneer, commission agent, del credere agent (guarantees payment by buyers); sub-agent and substituted agent.

Duties and rights

  • Agent's duties: follow instructions and customs, reasonable skill and diligence, render accounts, not make secret profit, not deal on own account, communicate with principal.
  • Agent's rights: remuneration, retainer, lien on principal's property, indemnity.
  • Principal's liability: bound by acts within actual or apparent authority; liable for agent's misrepresentation and fraud in the course of business.

Termination of agency (Section 201)

By revocation by principal, renunciation by agent, completion of business, death or insanity, insolvency of principal, expiry of time, destruction of subject matter. Irrevocable agency — where the agent has an interest in the subject matter (Section 202).

Example

Agent binding the principal: a property dealer appointed by Mr Singh agrees to sell his flat within the price and terms authorised. Mr Singh is bound by the sale even though he did not sign the agreement himself.

Exam tip

Learn modes of creating agency: express, implied, by necessity, by estoppel and by ratification.

Key terms

Contract
Agreement enforceable by law
Consideration
Something in return at the desire of the promisor
Surety
Person giving a guarantee for another's debt
Co-extensive liability
Surety liable to the same extent as the principal debtor
Agent
Person employed to act for another in dealings with third parties

Quick revision

  • Section 10 essentials; offer/acceptance rules; consideration exceptions.
  • Free consent vitiated by coercion, undue influence, fraud, misrepresentation, mistake.
  • Discharge modes and remedies (damages — Hadley v. Baxendale).
  • Guarantee: three parties; surety's rights — subrogation, indemnity, securities, contribution.
  • Agency: creation, kinds, duties, termination; irrevocable agency.

Important exam questions

Practice questions written to the PTU exam pattern for this unit's syllabus: short answers (Section A style) and long answers (Sections B and C style).

Short-answer questions

  1. Q1.State the essentials of a valid contract.
  2. Q2.What is a contingent contract?
  3. Q3.What is meant by "consensus ad idem"?
  4. Q4.What are the rights of a surety against the principal debtor?
  5. Q5.What is agency by necessity?
  6. Q6.How is an agency terminated?

Long-answer questions

  1. Q1.Explain the essentials of a valid contract with case laws.
  2. Q2.Explain the modes of discharge and remedies for breach of contract.
  3. Q3.Explain the contract of guarantee and the rights and liabilities of a surety.
  4. Q4.Explain the creation, classification and termination of agency.

Stuck on this unit?

Message SBS on WhatsApp for help with Legal Aspects of Business, or to ask about studying M.Com at Synetic.

Planning your M.Com in Ludhiana? See the M.Com at SBS →

WhatsApp us